What NBA players who you expected little suprised you? | The Boneyard

What NBA players who you expected little suprised you?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Aug 24, 2011
Messages
3,051
Reaction Score
6,254
Since someone has a thread about players that you thought would be NBA stars but ended up falling short, what about the ones you thought verly little of that turned out to be stars.

I must admit at the top of my list is Rondo. I flat out slammed Ainge for trading the pick before the draft even began, especially when Rudy was available where they had been picking. I even thought Marcus Williams would have been a far better choice than Rondo. I thought Rondo was one of the most overhyped college players I had ever seen. Boy did he turn out to be a steal for the C's when you consider where he was picked.

My gosh was I dead wrong. Although he still struggles shooting the ball from outside, at the stripe and sometimes finishing in traffic, he's turned out to be an incredibly productive player. He's a plus defender with those freakish long arms. He's creative with the ball, not to mention holds it like it's a grape in those huge hands of his. He's got a knack for making big plays on both ends of the floor, may it be stepping into a passing lane or slipping through tight spaces for layups or dishes.

I had my concerns about MW, especially on the defensive end. But I thought his playmaking abilities and good PG instincts would translate okay if he worked hard on his footwork and conditioning. I thought he could be a Deron Williams thick type PG, but he could barely find his way onto the floor. One thing to always keep in mind. If you can't defend, you better be exceptional at something if you want to play very long in the NBA. For example, as good a scorer Ben Gordon is, his minutes always seem to be limited due to his inability to stay in front of his man. Even Rip hit a PT wall, due to his defensive liabilities, and both he and Ben proved to be very good scorers at this level.

The NBA game is simply an unforgiving game. Unless you're on a crappy team, you have to bring something exception onto the floor for an NBA coach to give you starter's minutes.
 
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
1,533
Reaction Score
1,050
Rondo is a good one.

I'll go with:
Kevin Love: I thought he might be a decent player, but not an all star this quickly.
Russel Westbrook: I thought he's just be another Farmar, Afflalo type player.
J. Noah: I thought he was too awkward and didn't have enough offense to be a legit starter.
 

EricLA

Cronus
Joined
Aug 24, 2011
Messages
15,141
Reaction Score
82,947
Agree on Rondo. and Westbrook and Noah. I"ll also throw in Reddick. Really thought he as no better than that weeper Morrison. You can also add Jimmer Fredette to guys i thought would be a bust, but if he continues to average 7+ PPG as a pro and 18 MPG like he did for Sacramento, he won't be...
 
Joined
Aug 24, 2011
Messages
3,051
Reaction Score
6,254
Rondo is a good one.

I'll go with:
Kevin Love: I thought he might be a decent player, but not an all star this quickly.
Russel Westbrook: I thought he's just be another Farmar, Afflalo type player.
J. Noah: I thought he was too awkward and didn't have enough offense to be a legit starter.
I too am surprised how good Noah and Westbrook turned out. As for Love I thought he'd be a player. I thought his game would translate quite well to the NBA.
 
Joined
Aug 24, 2011
Messages
3,051
Reaction Score
6,254
Agree on Rondo. and Westbrook and Noah. I"ll also throw in Reddick. Really thought he as no better than that weeper Morrison. You can also add Jimmer Fredette to guys i thought would be a bust, but if he continues to average 7+ PPG as a pro and 18 MPG like he did for Sacramento, he won't be...
I expected Reddick to be somewhere between a bust and an outside sniper. He's been better than I thought but nowhere a star. As for Jimmer, I've not seen him play in the NBA, but those numbers you quoted weren't exactly eye popping.
 

CL82

NCAA Men’s Basketball National Champions - Again!
Joined
Aug 24, 2011
Messages
59,542
Reaction Score
222,788
Since someone has a thread about players that you thought would be NBA stars but ended up falling short, what about the ones you thought verly little of that turned out to be stars.

I must admit at the top of my list is Rondo. I flat out slammed Ainge for trading the pick before the draft even began, especially when Rudy was available where they had been picking. I even thought Marcus Williams would have been a far better choice than Rondo. I thought Rondo was one of the most overhyped college players I had ever seen. Boy did he turn out to be a steal for the C's when you consider where he was picked.

My gosh was I dead wrong. Although he still struggles shooting the ball from outside, at the stripe and sometimes finishing in traffic, he's turned out to be an incredibly productive player. He's a plus defender with those freakish long arms. He's creative with the ball, not to mention holds it like it's a grape in those huge hands of his. He's got a knack for making big plays on both ends of the floor, may it be stepping into a passing lane or slipping through tight spaces for layups or dishes.

I had my concerns about MW, especially on the defensive end. But I thought his playmaking abilities and good PG instincts would translate okay if he worked hard on his footwork and conditioning. I thought he could be a Deron Williams thick type PG, but he could barely find his way onto the floor. One thing to always keep in mind. If you can't defend, you better be exceptional at something if you want to play very long in the NBA. For example, as good a scorer Ben Gordon is, his minutes always seem to be limited due to his inability to stay in front of his man. Even Rip hit a PT wall, due to his defensive liabilities, and both he and Ben proved to be very good scorers at this level.

The NBA game is simply an unforgiving game. Unless you're on a crappy team, you have to bring something exception onto the floor for an NBA coach to give you starter's minutes.

Same.
 

EricLA

Cronus
Joined
Aug 24, 2011
Messages
15,141
Reaction Score
82,947
I expected Reddick to be somewhere between a bust and an outside sniper. He's been better than I thought but nowhere a star. As for Jimmer, I've not seen him play in the NBA, but those numbers you quoted weren't exactly eye popping.
I was actually talking about guys i thought would be busts but weren't. didn't catch that you said "stars".
 

GemParty

Co~host of the Sliders & Curveballs Podcast
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
3,457
Reaction Score
6,971
Roy Hibbert
James Harden
Jameer Nelson
 
Joined
Dec 31, 2011
Messages
307
Reaction Score
814
I actually really liked Rondo's upside despite his lack of shooting ability. I also loved Love's potential and thought he might actually be the best player in that draft. The ones I was way off on are:

Tim Duncan - I didn't think he would be an all star, let alone a first ballot hall of famer
Deron Williams - Either I didn't see enough of him in college or I seriously underestimated how good he would be. I couldn't believe he was picked over Chris Paul (he shouldn't have been even now). I didn't think he could be a starter but never imagined that he would be an all star.
Derrick Rose - I thought he would be a decent player with potential all star, but I couldn't believe he was a consensus 1st overall and eventually an MVP award. He didn't have much of J in college and I wasn't all that impressed with his playmaking.
Joakim Noah - He's quietly become a very good NBA player. I thought he was marginally more skilled than Josh Boone.
 
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
3,217
Reaction Score
10,690
I was surprised by Deron Williams as well. He wasnt even the best player on that 2005 final four team. It always seemed like Dee Brown was "the guy" on those illinois teams. Williams only averaged about 10-12 points over his 3 year college career. Similar to Tony Robertson type numbers
 
Joined
Feb 16, 2012
Messages
3,007
Reaction Score
3,946
I too am surprised how good Noah and Westbrook turned out. As for Love I thought he'd be a player. I thought his game would translate quite well to the NBA.
Really? You thought that Love would be this good?
Off the top of my head, in no particular order:
Love
Rondo
Parker (Tony, that is)
Monte Ellis
Jameer Nelson
Michael Redd (career derailed by injuries)
Noah
Horford
Jeremy Lin (still too early I know)
Chauncy Billups
Tayshaun Prince
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
1,604
Reaction Score
4,437
I liked deron Williams coming out. Didn't score more cause he didnt have too but he was def the best player on that team. Gerald Wallace was a guy who I thought would stink but turned into a nice player.
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
9,397
Reaction Score
34,455
Paul Pierce. Never thought he would make it. Flabby arms, not terribly quick and didn't appear to be willing to work hard.

Hall of Famer and durable as hell.
I don't care if he was a top 10, I was totally surprised.
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
10,441
Reaction Score
34,839
Isiah Thomas from washington, who now plays for sacramento. Stephon Curry. Demarcus Cousins.

Thomas is better than Fredette and was the last pick in the draft, I didn't expect him to even make a roster let alone play as well as he did in his rookie season.
 
Joined
Aug 29, 2011
Messages
4,322
Reaction Score
7,421
Tracy McGready
Amare Stoudemire
Jermaine O'Neal - his early career and awful last 4yrs notwithstanding he was an all-star in his prime
Basically I take an admittedly biased "prove me wrong" theory to most high schoolers unless freak exceptions (Garnett, Kobe, LeBron and oops Kwame B)

Among those that played in college:
Kyrie Irving - thought it'd take a few years as with most PG, particularly inexperienced
Mutombo - better pro than college player
Vin Baker - I thought he didn't have strength & was too quirky when played against UConn at Htfd, no solace taken with end of career probs
 

nelsonmuntz

Point Center
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
44,629
Reaction Score
34,621
I didn't think Boozer would last 3 years in the pros. I thought he was unathletic and undersized, a bad combination. He has worked incredibly hard.
 
Joined
Aug 29, 2011
Messages
242
Reaction Score
630
Larry Bird-- thought he was way too slow.

Way way off on this one too. When it happened I thought Bellamy and Komives
were to much to trade for Debusschere
 

JaYnYcE

Soul Brother
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
2,245
Reaction Score
852
Made the All-Star Rookie/Sophomore game. Definitely didn't see that coming.

 

nomar

#1 Casual Fan™
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
16,240
Reaction Score
47,036
Steph Curry - I thought he would be a bust. A shooting guard in a midget's body.

Westbrook & Harden - I definitely did not see this coming.

Love - If you say you expected him to lead the NBA in rebounding and hit a truckload of 3's, you're a liar.

I didn't think Kyle Lowry would be a starting NBA PG.

Kawhi Leonard surprised me this year.

Now I'm just rambling. There are probably scores of guys in the NBA who I didn't think would make it. And scores of guys I was sure would.
 
Joined
Jul 31, 2013
Messages
2,660
Reaction Score
6,585
I want to throw Jimmy Butler in here. One of those Big East opponents whose game I always respected, but I definitely didnt think he'd do what he's been doing. He definitely landed in a perfect situation to make a splash playing for a team that needed his position and is in the limelight a bit.

Michael Carter-Williams hasn't had enough time to really show if he's a long-term success, but I didn't see him putting out games ever that he did multiple times in his rookie year. He hasn't done anything yet, but I'm still surprised with what I've seen Jeremy Lamb become. I didn't think he had the drive and work ethic to transform his body, but he did, so I think he will have a paycheck in the NBA for years to come now that he's shown that.

I agree with Steph Curry, thought he'd be a big time bust, I Thomas too.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Online statistics

Members online
348
Guests online
2,553
Total visitors
2,901

Forum statistics

Threads
160,146
Messages
4,219,001
Members
10,082
Latest member
Basingstoke


.
Top Bottom