I'm not giving up on this team, but one thing I've noticed is a lack of B-Ball instinct. Hurley has praised these guys saying they have a high B-Ball IQ, but you to have instinct as well. Of the guys getting regular minutes, Karaban and McNeeley are the only ones I see have it. Other guys may know how to play and where everyone and the ball should be at times, but there's a difference between that and that 'voice' or whatever it is inside you to to read a ball off of a shooter's hand and know you need to move to a different spot for the rebound, or your guys is covered now, but give him another second and he'll be open with a lane to get him the ball.
Cam Spencer is a guy who is not the most athletic guy. If he had Ball's athleticism, he would have been a top 3 pick. He just knows how to play and learned on defense to use his feet enough and use his quick hands.
The last 2 teams have been blessed having multiple guys on each team like Sanogo, Jackson, Newton, Joey 'California', Karaban and especially Clingan and Newton. Others here have aluded to it, but I don't think many truly realize how special Clingan's mere presence on the court was. He was 7' plus feet, and when healthy, very mobile and instinctive to the ball. His ability to help and recover is truly special.
Newton, outside of Storrs, did not/has not received enough credit for what he did for these 2 teams. Again, he is not going to blow you away with his athleticism, but the dude can just play.
I still have hope because it is early, and remember that Newton did struggle for a while in 22'/23' especially in Big East play. However, now much of this hinges on the health of Karaban. If he is out for a long period or this is something that lingers throughout the season, this team could very well finish below .500.