Honestly, what is so hard to understand that the answer can be "both"?
As for the "cupboard was bare" when Edsall left - at QB, it was undeniable. Probably WR and OL too. That doesn't mean that there wasn't good talent elsewhere.
Then you add in crappy coaching (P, GDL)- and you start flirting with disaster.
Then you lose what talent you do have on D, along with a solid DC... continued awful coaching of the OL... and you have an unequivical disaster. Weist and the guys are doing the best they can to fix it but there's a lot to fix.
So why do people hammer Dez when he says Edsall left the cupboard bare, but now those same people are now coming to the conclusion that we have a lack of talent on this team?
Is the consensus now that Dez was right? It's OK to say he was, Silver said the cupboard was bare too. I don't feel that way, I think our coaching is terrible, but I see so many people in here writing about the huge drop off in talent, those people should just say Dez was right because most of the P recruits are either redshirt freshman or true freshman, everyone else is an Edsall guy.
A lot of people owe Dez an apology. Don't hammer him for expressing an opinion you agree with.
My argument is the coaching is so bad it has driven the talent into the ground, nobody is being coached up. It was not so noticeable the previous two years because Don Brown was actually a good coach that landed in P's lap. But God forbid I say nice things about Brown, that causes problems for some people, even though he elevates defensive performance everywhere he goes, not just here.