Provy plays almost everyone close be it Q1 or Q4. Not great but at some point you are what your record says you are. Creighton is the #3 team in the Big East standings today. Creighton is 4-7 in Q1/Q2 games. Friars are 10-2. That seems like a gap.If PC was a wide gap ahead of the #3 team, they wouldn't have just gone to OT against Depaul. They've executed in crunch time better than anyone this year - but the other 35 minutes of the games they have played nearly even basketball in 80% of their conference games. If there was a wide gap, they wouldn't have 8 games decided by less than 4 points.
If you are grading teams on who they take to OT or who gives whom a tough game in the Big East than you might be missing something.