Underrated US Cities | Page 11 | The Boneyard

Underrated US Cities

storrsroars

Exiled in Pittsburgh
Joined
Mar 23, 2012
Messages
21,306
Reaction Score
46,845
I noticed that Nashville hasn't appeared on this list. I expected it might, but maybe it isn't underrated but properly highly rated. I have not been, but just booked flights last Friday to go down in late September with another couple. Kicking off our quasi empty-nest life.
Don't stay at Opryland. It's a trap. It's like staying in Lowell to visit Boston. I used to have to go to Opryland on occasion back when I was in the convention business. It was a PITA and $$$ to get to downtown Nashville if you didn't have a rental car.
 

HuskyHawk

The triumphant return of the Blues Brothers.
Joined
Sep 12, 2011
Messages
33,193
Reaction Score
86,559
Don't stay at Opryland. It's a trap. It's like staying in Lowell to visit Boston. I used to have to go to Opryland on occasion back when I was in the convention business. It was a PITA and $$$ to get to downtown Nashville if you didn't have a rental car.

We will probably have a car, but definitely didn't plan to stay there. We will want bar hopping and live music type environment. Kind of an alternative to New Orleans. Where to Stay in Nashville | Nashville Guru
 
Joined
Mar 3, 2020
Messages
94
Reaction Score
408
Between my two careers (baseball and chemical sales) I have lived in 12 different states and 18 different cities. My favorite smaller cities were Sarasota, Colorado Springs, Richmond, Mt Pleasant, SC, Wilmington, NC, and Boone, NC. My second home is in Mt Pleasant, which is great because it is so close to Charleston. Love the restaurants and the golf in the area.

First time I went to Boone, I kept seeing ASU stickers on the cars and couldn't believe so many people in the area went to Arizona State. Sometimes, I'm not the sharpest knife in the drawer! Great fishing, hiking, etc in Boone, plus it is a college town, just not the ASU I thought. Most of these same things attracted me to Colorado Springs.

Love the beaches, fishing, restaurants in Sarasota and Wilmington. Richmond is my hometown and like the way they have upgraded a lot of things. Great craft brewery scene and restaurants in the city, but I would live in the burbs vs downtown.
 

WestHartHusk

$3M a Year With March Off
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
4,626
Reaction Score
14,165
I noticed that Nashville hasn't appeared on this list. I expected it might, but maybe it isn't underrated but properly highly rated. I have not been, but just booked flights last Friday to go down in late September with another couple. Kicking off our quasi empty-nest life.
I was waiting for the most over-rated city thread to drop Nashville in.
 
Joined
Jun 9, 2017
Messages
6,479
Reaction Score
25,800
Between my two careers (baseball and chemical sales) I have lived in 12 different states and 18 different cities. My favorite smaller cities were Sarasota, Colorado Springs, Richmond, Mt Pleasant, SC, Wilmington, NC, and Boone, NC. My second home is in Mt Pleasant, which is great because it is so close to Charleston. Love the restaurants and the golf in the area.

First time I went to Boone, I kept seeing ASU stickers on the cars and couldn't believe so many people in the area went to Arizona State. Sometimes, I'm not the sharpest knife in the drawer! Great fishing, hiking, etc in Boone, plus it is a college town, just not the ASU I thought. Most of these same things attracted me to Colorado Springs.

Love the beaches, fishing, restaurants in Sarasota and Wilmington. Richmond is my hometown and like the way they have upgraded a lot of things. Great craft brewery scene and restaurants in the city, but I would live in the burbs vs downtown.

i haven’t spent any time there, but I know a few people that absolutely love Richmond.
 

Mr. French

Tremendous Individual
Joined
Feb 10, 2012
Messages
4,019
Reaction Score
16,098
If you're going to pitch Buffalo, I'll add Rochester. Both get a bad rap because of snow without skiing, but, yes, there's lots to like for those who live there or visit.

Amazingly, I've never really spent much time hanging out in Rochester. Tons of my friends went to school there, I've traveled there for basketball a bunch and to Bills training camp at St. John Fisher, but as for hanging out in the city of Rochester it's probably been 20 years and very infrequent. It's strange. But both having a similar feel for sure and with aspects of the city right on a great lake, the summers are solid in both cities.

Buffalo's surrounding areas are awesome as well - I know most people think of a city but Buffalo does truly encompass much of their surrounding areas as well and there's tons of excellent breweries, skiing, amazing food and the people are generally super nice.

As for our actual city, as I said it's not perfect and still tons of things holding it back, but we've made some real progress in recent years and certain parts of the city are downright charming and booming.

I haven't traveled to as many cool places as I wish, but I did love my week or so in Boulder, though it's been roughly 10 years. Boulder/Denver area is definitely a trip I'm looking forward to soon.
 

OkaForPrez

Really Popular Poster
Joined
Aug 28, 2011
Messages
5,207
Reaction Score
26,704
Dunedin Florida makes my list:

Pre season baseball, bike trail 30 min south to Clearwater, 50 min north to tarpon, 20 min over the bridge to honeymoon island. Plenty of breweries on the trail in between. More local vibe than Clearwater which has outgrown its britches.
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
13,218
Reaction Score
32,475
'As pointed out elsewhere, many US cities have done similarly, annexing adjacent towns and even entire counties (like done or all of Louisville, Columbus, San Antonio, and Indianapolis have), and become healthier for it.'
u forgot the other side of this point, ie, the complete opposite.
people just don't like crime, particularly when they feel their government isn't doing a darn thing to fix the problem. imagine that.
'Atlanta is now partly surrounded by breakaway cities, from South Fulton on its southwestern edge, Sandy Springs to the north and Brookhaven just east of Buckhead.'
'Arguments for creating an independent Buckhead have leaned heavily on what some say is uncontrolled crime throughout Atlanta.'
City of Buckhead: Data shows what proposed Buckhead City would look like (ajc.com)
and not an uncommon trend nowadays. i very much like Atlanta the way it is, but i don't count, cuz i don't actually live there.
There is an understandable appeal for the point of view you advance, but that moves things beyond the nature of the thread. I sought only to offer that consolidated Stamford runs 40-50 square miles and incorporates multi-acreage, higher income back-country residents, whereas Hartford, Bridgeport, and New Haven are all smaller than 20 square miles, and, in effect, 'prove out' this later argument of yours by 'allowing,' for example, West Hartford, Fairfield to have vibrant downtowns as separate municipalities that were formed in the 19th and 17th Centuries respectively, and simply have to maintain a 'no encroachment' posture to, 'functionally' strand Hartford and Bridgeport with the common urban ills that beset most post-industrial American cities that thrived before automobiles, highways, single-family home ownership, computers, an information-service economy, and such...not to mention the collosal irony that air conditioning that originated from Syracuse's Carrier Corporation further transformed the South's livability and growth.

I'm only suggesting that in most of the US, Hartford, New Haven, and Bridgeport would present as 300,000 person cities in 800,000 person metropolitan areas, and their wealth & economic vitality, natural beauty, history, culture, and ethnic-racial diversity would all compare attractively throughout the country.
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
13,218
Reaction Score
32,475
It definitely sucks. Back when I started coming here regularly in the late 90s, this was one of the three USAirways hubs and you could literally get a direct flight from all three NYC airports, plus HPN, BDL, PVD, BOS and MHT, and prices were reasonable. When I moved here in 2002, we could get most anywhere on a direct flight from here through 2004, and we did. It was fantastic. Then USAir abandoned PGH as a hub (after we built them a new billion dollar terminal) and it's sucked since.

I have no idea what prices will be, but supposedly direct flights to LGA, JFK, EWR and BOS will resume on May 5, in most cases 3 flights/day.
What a drag. I hadn't known of this change. That would be major.

I still anticipate that my next visit to Pittsburgh, where I was born, will be a road trip half-way stop that continues to Louisville. The last time I did that was 20 years ago, and I got to witness the implosion of Three Rivers Stadium.
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
2,268
Reaction Score
6,024
Traverse City, Mi has a good vibe in the summer. Matter of opinion but the west-northwest coast of Michigan's mitten is rather fun.

I second that. Was there 4 years ago and it was nice. Great number of golf courses as well!
 
Joined
Sep 16, 2011
Messages
51,054
Reaction Score
182,295
Not sure if any of them would be considered underrated, probably not but some of the Canadian cities seem great. I love Vancouver and Montreal. Haven't been to Toronto yet but hear really good things about it and skyscrapers are going up like crazy. One of my next trips has to be to Quebec City, never been but know I would love it. Looks great for summer or winter but around Christmas looks magical.
 
Joined
Jun 9, 2017
Messages
6,479
Reaction Score
25,800
Not sure if any of them would be considered underrated, probably not but some of the Canadian cities seem great. I love Vancouver and Montreal. Haven't been to Toronto yet but hear really good things about it and skyscrapers are going up like crazy. One of my next trips has to be to Quebec City, never been but know I would love it. Looks great for summer or winter but around Christmas looks magical.
We’re definitely getting out of the “underrated” range but Quebec City>>>Montreal
 
Joined
Dec 8, 2015
Messages
13,473
Reaction Score
102,961
Not sure if any of them would be considered underrated, probably not but some of the Canadian cities seem great. I love Vancouver and Montreal. Haven't been to Toronto yet but hear really good things about it and skyscrapers are going up like crazy. One of my next trips has to be to Quebec City, never been but know I would love it. Looks great for summer or winter but around Christmas looks magical.

Quebec city is the bomb. It's the only place in North America you feel like you're in an old European city. Great food (poutine!), super fun around Christmas time with the market.
 
Joined
Aug 16, 2015
Messages
3,552
Reaction Score
10,194
In spirit and celebration to people returning to travel again, which US cities did you enjoy when visiting/living in but aren't "well-known" popular or trendy spots?

Salt Lake City: Granted, I was here during March Madness, but it's surrounded by the Rockies, a walkable downtown and despite an inability to drink super well, enjoyable restaurants/bars/breweries. I was there for basketball, but enjoyed the city much more than I expected I would.

Fargo, ND: My in-laws grew up in hour outside of the city and I was there for a North Dakota State game, which was fun. However, I really liked the downtown, the Donaldson is an incredible hotel and overall had a nice vibe.

Rapid City, SD: Smack in the middle of touristy areas, Grand Rapids is a surprisingly "cool" city, despite being very family/touristy friendly. Street art, good food, fun city!

Flagstaff, AZ: I hated Sedona, but loved Flagstaff. Incredible weather, beautiful scenery, excellent food. Still has the new age-y stuff of Sedona, just in a much more approachable and "tasteful" way.
Rapid City is just nice climate. It's right outside where the jet stream carries artic temperatures south. Thus it's considerably warmer than anything a couple hours east.
 
Joined
May 7, 2014
Messages
14,728
Reaction Score
30,969
People thought the small brewery/craft beer bubble would pop over a decade ago, it ain't going anywhere and will most likely only be stronger as people have largely been in their homes for over a year with limited socializing. People will be hitting breweries, restaurants, and traveling like crazy for the next couple of years. Craft beer is one of the best stories of America's economy, IMO. In a country that's run by Walmart and Amazon it feels like the one little guy business which has been kicking butt for years.
And then you learn how many of the truly successful ones rely on a buyout by InBev...

I have limited to contribute to this thread because I’ve only lived in and travel to major cities. Will be in SLC late summer and expecting good things though.
 

storrsroars

Exiled in Pittsburgh
Joined
Mar 23, 2012
Messages
21,306
Reaction Score
46,845
Not sure if any of them would be considered underrated, probably not but some of the Canadian cities seem great. I love Vancouver and Montreal. Haven't been to Toronto yet but hear really good things about it and skyscrapers are going up like crazy. One of my next trips has to be to Quebec City, never been but know I would love it. Looks great for summer or winter but around Christmas looks magical.
I used to love going to Toronto at first, but I've been there more than a dozen times now, got to know some of the neighborhoods, and I realized there's nothing about Toronto that screams, "warm and welcoming" anywhere in the city. While there's plenty to do, I never got the sense that there was a particular "character" about the city, its neighborhoods, or its residents, like say Chicago, NYC, Boston or even Montreal. Plus, it's become this giant megaopolis that seems to stretch from Hamilton to Oshawa. Mississagua might be the world's largest city where "there's no 'there' there".
 
Last edited:

Drew

Its a post, about nothing!
Joined
Jun 19, 2013
Messages
7,982
Reaction Score
29,203
I noticed that Nashville hasn't appeared on this list. I expected it might, but maybe it isn't underrated but properly highly rated. I have not been, but just booked flights last Friday to go down in late September with another couple. Kicking off our quasi empty-nest life.
Should’ve waited until October 9 and watched the Huskies beat a SEC team!
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
13,757
Reaction Score
143,855
Santa Rosa in Cali. Lived there for a year+. Small walkable city, not too busy, Russian River brewing company, great music and only short drive to some other great cities like Petaluma and Healdsburg. Also 30 minutes from the coast and an hour drive to SF. Loved every minute there.
 
Joined
Aug 25, 2011
Messages
14,051
Reaction Score
75,074
I used to love going to Toronto at first, but I've been there more than a dozen times now, got to know some of the neighborhoods, and I realized there's nothing about Toronto that screams, "warm and welcoming" anywhere in the city. While there's plenty to do, I never got the sense that there was a particular "character" about the city, its neighborhoods, or its residents, like say Chicago, NYC, Boston or even Montreal. Plus, it's become this giant megaopolis that seems to stretch from Hamilton to Oshawa. Mississagua might be the world's largest city where "there's no 'there' there".

Agreed, it's a big city like a lot of other big cities, but I never got a whiff of any character. In terms of Canadian cities Montreal and Vancouver have it beat. Quebec City is cool but really small. For my money Montreal is the better spot to visit.
 

HuskyHawk

The triumphant return of the Blues Brothers.
Joined
Sep 12, 2011
Messages
33,193
Reaction Score
86,559
Santa Rosa in Cali. Lived there for a year+. Small walkable city, not too busy, Russian River brewing company, great music and only short drive to some other great cities like Petaluma and Healdsburg. Also 30 minutes from the coast and an hour drive to SF. Loved every minute there.

Wine country is terrific. Very nice area. Lots of nice towns up there. The fall is vastly underrated. Cool temps, no crowds, leaves on vines changing colors. Charming.

I have a soft spot for Santa Cruz as well, even if it stinks of BO, weed and Patchouli oil away from the beach and boardwalk. It’s got an attitude that doesn’t give two poops what you think if it. Another spectacular physical setting too. Views from UCSC are amazing.
 

Online statistics

Members online
317
Guests online
2,456
Total visitors
2,773

Forum statistics

Threads
161,225
Messages
4,255,306
Members
10,098
Latest member
Hillside


.
Top Bottom