- Joined
- Sep 14, 2011
- Messages
- 2,676
- Reaction Score
- 6,257
I've posted several times why I think the polls are important, although most will say they care little or nothing about them and the only poll that matters is in April. For one thing, I believe polls affect recruiting. When a team is in the polls, they're in the "conversation" and when they're in the conversation, recruits take notice.
I've been tracking certain aspects of the polls since 2003 -- well, one aspect of the polls, anyway, first place votes. A first place vote means that someone with enough respect to have been chosen by the poll's administrators to cast a ballot sees that team as the best.
A special aspect of first place ballots is that it signifies that ALL voters agree. Unanimous agreement is far from simple to achieve. 30+ opinionated individuals must all think the same team is the best. Achieving unanimous agreement in both polls is harder still.
Want an example of how difficult it is to achieve unanimity? I offer boy genius Seth Soffian. Seth writes for something called the News-Press and has been given a vote in the AP poll. Anyway, Seth doesn't deserve his #1 vote. As Seth put his rationale for choosing a team other than UConn this week, "Everyone knows UConn is still going to be the team to beat. But the Huskies haven't played a game yet, and South Carolina beating an Ohio State team that's good enough to be a Final Four contender is impressive enough to warrant a No. 1 vote, at least for now."
So UConn won't be the unanimous #1 in the AP this week. Anybody want to offer that mindless pot-stirrer Seth a one-finger salute?
Know what's even more difficult than being the unanimous in both polls for a given week? Being the unanimous #1 in both polls for an entire season. Any guesses as to which team achieved that? Unfortunately, as dominant as UConn may prove to be this season, they won't be unanimous all season. Thanks, Seth.
I've been tracking certain aspects of the polls since 2003 -- well, one aspect of the polls, anyway, first place votes. A first place vote means that someone with enough respect to have been chosen by the poll's administrators to cast a ballot sees that team as the best.
A special aspect of first place ballots is that it signifies that ALL voters agree. Unanimous agreement is far from simple to achieve. 30+ opinionated individuals must all think the same team is the best. Achieving unanimous agreement in both polls is harder still.
Want an example of how difficult it is to achieve unanimity? I offer boy genius Seth Soffian. Seth writes for something called the News-Press and has been given a vote in the AP poll. Anyway, Seth doesn't deserve his #1 vote. As Seth put his rationale for choosing a team other than UConn this week, "Everyone knows UConn is still going to be the team to beat. But the Huskies haven't played a game yet, and South Carolina beating an Ohio State team that's good enough to be a Final Four contender is impressive enough to warrant a No. 1 vote, at least for now."
So UConn won't be the unanimous #1 in the AP this week. Anybody want to offer that mindless pot-stirrer Seth a one-finger salute?
Know what's even more difficult than being the unanimous in both polls for a given week? Being the unanimous #1 in both polls for an entire season. Any guesses as to which team achieved that? Unfortunately, as dominant as UConn may prove to be this season, they won't be unanimous all season. Thanks, Seth.