Hate to be a downer but all it did was keep UConn from finishing 4-8. But this is the point of lists: to spark debate. I don't have to agree with your reasoning, in order to understand it.
My personal list includes: Notre Dame, Iowa State, South Florida (in the monsoon), Louisville (fair catch game), and Pittsburgh (2 OT at home) Baylor. Honerable mentions go to South Florida to get into the BCS, Baylor, and Indiana (First game at the Rent, established a field advantage).
Iowa State was the most thrilling. Remember listening to it on the radio and being in total shock that we were blowing them out. At that time I didn't think UConn would have a winning season for years to come.
I was in a drive through window listening on the radio to the Iowa St game in San Diego when Terry broke off his long run and sealed the deal.
Amazing. I was screaming like an idiot.
Hopefully an In n Out Drive Thru?
I always feel like the Iowa State win or the absolute drubbing of Wake Forest belong in there somehow, since both were critically important to the psyche of the program (it showed that we could play like "big boys"), but it's hard to top any of the five that you've mentioned...
That Rutgers game was great. I can't believe nobody brought up DJ Hernandez's win against Pitt in 2OT. Significance/importance aside, I think that was probably the most exciting game I can recall, although @ND was awfully close. I guess when you factor in competitiveness of the game I'd have to say @ND was our best win. Maybe not our most important but definitely top 5, maybe not our most exciting, but definitely top 5, so it probably is what I would consider our top win.
This year's Louisville game isn't one of the Top 5. Nice win, but it had no positive impact on the program whatsoever. In fact, it might have had a negative impact as a loss may have led to P getting sacked.
A few of us brought up Pitt in 2OT.