UcMiami
How it is
- Joined
- Aug 26, 2011
- Messages
- 14,190
- Reaction Score
- 47,262
So, Nan started a thread a few weeks ago asking what was going on with the board which she locked quickly. I asked a few questions on PM and found that the mods had been deleting a lot of posts and that some long time members of the board had terminated their participation because of the tone on the board and attacks on them. It seems we have a lot of new members, or newly active members, and we have a bunch of new visitors (fans of other teams.) I have been thinking about posting something during the last week - sort of my personal experience, my paean to this board, its members and moderators, and a bit of a plea for maintaining it's standards. This is probably going to be pretty long:
Me - I've been a sports fan my whole life and started following UConn WCBB during the 1995 season, but became more fanatic around 2000. As time has passed and various pro games have changed I find my sports fandom has narrowed to UConn, the Patriots, and occasional professional league playoffs. And my passion is the UConn women.
WCBB - We fans of this sport remain a minority and while UConn gets lots of coverage and has a very active fan base, most WCBB fans get served the dregs of coverage. It make those who are passionate about the sport and any specific team into a community who may ardently dislike other teams, but who have more in common with those other teams fans than with sports fandom in general - they too deal with the slings and arrows directed at their heroes by bozos who cannot appreciate the skill and artistry of the athletes they support. And we are all starved of the quality of coverage for the sport in general that men's sports receive. Remember that!
Sports Forums - I spend some time on other sports boards, but less and less. There are occasionally interesting discussions that last for a few posts in a row, before they devolve into babbling BS with flame wars and stupidity. Occasionally there is some breaking news, but in general the time taken to weed through the crap being posted for the occasional gems is just not worth it. With WCBB the Baylor site and the TN site are the two I visit and occasionally post on - Baylor is well moderated, TN tends to be hostile to visitors and has been having a running battle between the Holly fans and the Holly haters and that overwhelms pretty much everything else at the moment. The ND and SC sites are just too hard to deal with the format and are surprisingly sparse of real discussion or analysis. And then there is the Boneyard!
The Boneyard and its moderators - When I found this site years ago, it was amazing. A place to go to get news and analysis of UConn WCBB that was regulated and did not have pages of meaningless drivel to wade through. I lurked for a few years and then got the courage to start making posts, and 10,000 later it is hard to shut me up! This place became a daily visit, and then a place to check in a few times a day because there was so much information being posted (and so many opinions that needed to be corrected! ) And it was not just UConn fans, but fans of other teams were bringing useful information and different perspectives to the discussion. And the moderators kept the wheels greased and weeded out or shut down things that got out of hand. Occasionally it seemed a little heavy handed, but you have a choice in many areas of life - complete freedom and anarchy, or putting rules in place and someone to inforce those rules, and having moments where your freedom is a little curtailed. I choose the latter because I visit sites with the former and do not enjoy them. I applaud our moderators, do not envy them the tasks they perform, and hope everyone else respects the authority we have vested in them as a community.
New posters and new visitors: Please take time to appreciate what distinguishes the boneyard from other sports forums. If you haven't visited other forums, chose a sport and a site and read some threads, especially for men's money sports. Check out the comments sections of web postings or ESPN comments sections, or the comments on newspaper articles. And then read a thread here and really think about the difference - no poster is being called names, players aren't being denigrated, and the discussions and disputes are civil and thoughtful, usually backed up with some stats. It isn't perfect, but it is so much more interesting and informative.
For all posters - a few rules to live by:
1. If some post makes you angry, walk away and think about your response before you post it. Is it actually advancing a discussion or just negating what the post said?
2. There are no winners being declared in a discussion, and do you really have to have the 'last word'? or have you grown up since that was of paramount importance?
3. Have you already said the same thing in the same thread?
4. Visitors - understand that we are very protective of our team (as no doubt you are of yours) and see the world through national flag blue glasses. Be a little respectful of that.
5. UConn fans - visitors really do add a lot to our experience here, and unfortunately if they are WCBB fans they don't have a lot of other places to go for the breadth of information and discussion that happens here. Not every thing has to be us vs. them, our player vs. their player. Praising a star player on another team is not an attack on UConn. And telling them to go home is really childish. If you think they are out of line there is a 'report' button on every post - let the moderators know and let them handle it. If you disagree with their opinion, fine, post a reply but try to make it interesting.
6. Try to make the moderators life easier! Think before you post!
7. If you enjoy the standard sports forum and want to have that experience of trash talking - maybe find a different forum. There are others where former yarders hang that enjoy that stuff. You can still visit here for the information, but maybe get your kicks elsewhere.
So if this survives and you got to this point - wow! You are dedicated.
Me - I've been a sports fan my whole life and started following UConn WCBB during the 1995 season, but became more fanatic around 2000. As time has passed and various pro games have changed I find my sports fandom has narrowed to UConn, the Patriots, and occasional professional league playoffs. And my passion is the UConn women.
WCBB - We fans of this sport remain a minority and while UConn gets lots of coverage and has a very active fan base, most WCBB fans get served the dregs of coverage. It make those who are passionate about the sport and any specific team into a community who may ardently dislike other teams, but who have more in common with those other teams fans than with sports fandom in general - they too deal with the slings and arrows directed at their heroes by bozos who cannot appreciate the skill and artistry of the athletes they support. And we are all starved of the quality of coverage for the sport in general that men's sports receive. Remember that!
Sports Forums - I spend some time on other sports boards, but less and less. There are occasionally interesting discussions that last for a few posts in a row, before they devolve into babbling BS with flame wars and stupidity. Occasionally there is some breaking news, but in general the time taken to weed through the crap being posted for the occasional gems is just not worth it. With WCBB the Baylor site and the TN site are the two I visit and occasionally post on - Baylor is well moderated, TN tends to be hostile to visitors and has been having a running battle between the Holly fans and the Holly haters and that overwhelms pretty much everything else at the moment. The ND and SC sites are just too hard to deal with the format and are surprisingly sparse of real discussion or analysis. And then there is the Boneyard!
The Boneyard and its moderators - When I found this site years ago, it was amazing. A place to go to get news and analysis of UConn WCBB that was regulated and did not have pages of meaningless drivel to wade through. I lurked for a few years and then got the courage to start making posts, and 10,000 later it is hard to shut me up! This place became a daily visit, and then a place to check in a few times a day because there was so much information being posted (and so many opinions that needed to be corrected! ) And it was not just UConn fans, but fans of other teams were bringing useful information and different perspectives to the discussion. And the moderators kept the wheels greased and weeded out or shut down things that got out of hand. Occasionally it seemed a little heavy handed, but you have a choice in many areas of life - complete freedom and anarchy, or putting rules in place and someone to inforce those rules, and having moments where your freedom is a little curtailed. I choose the latter because I visit sites with the former and do not enjoy them. I applaud our moderators, do not envy them the tasks they perform, and hope everyone else respects the authority we have vested in them as a community.
New posters and new visitors: Please take time to appreciate what distinguishes the boneyard from other sports forums. If you haven't visited other forums, chose a sport and a site and read some threads, especially for men's money sports. Check out the comments sections of web postings or ESPN comments sections, or the comments on newspaper articles. And then read a thread here and really think about the difference - no poster is being called names, players aren't being denigrated, and the discussions and disputes are civil and thoughtful, usually backed up with some stats. It isn't perfect, but it is so much more interesting and informative.
For all posters - a few rules to live by:
1. If some post makes you angry, walk away and think about your response before you post it. Is it actually advancing a discussion or just negating what the post said?
2. There are no winners being declared in a discussion, and do you really have to have the 'last word'? or have you grown up since that was of paramount importance?
3. Have you already said the same thing in the same thread?
4. Visitors - understand that we are very protective of our team (as no doubt you are of yours) and see the world through national flag blue glasses. Be a little respectful of that.
5. UConn fans - visitors really do add a lot to our experience here, and unfortunately if they are WCBB fans they don't have a lot of other places to go for the breadth of information and discussion that happens here. Not every thing has to be us vs. them, our player vs. their player. Praising a star player on another team is not an attack on UConn. And telling them to go home is really childish. If you think they are out of line there is a 'report' button on every post - let the moderators know and let them handle it. If you disagree with their opinion, fine, post a reply but try to make it interesting.
6. Try to make the moderators life easier! Think before you post!
7. If you enjoy the standard sports forum and want to have that experience of trash talking - maybe find a different forum. There are others where former yarders hang that enjoy that stuff. You can still visit here for the information, but maybe get your kicks elsewhere.
So if this survives and you got to this point - wow! You are dedicated.