Great post Biz. Again, thank you for doing these.
I actually think the defense let this team down for the first time this season and it's hard to be too critical of them given how well they have played most of the season and being without 4 DEs for all intent and purposes. The other issue is that this team was not ready to play a big game. The TOs and struggles to get the right personnel on the field on the 12th game of the season certainly indicates to me this team is not well coached. But, more than anything, I think Cincy is just a better team this season and we needed to play an almost perfect game to beat them.
As for the offense, I don't know what to say. I think McCombs is a very good college footabll player and goodness knows there is not a tougher one on the planet. But, he is badly mis-used. At 160 he simply cannot break through even arm tackles. As a result, those 3-4 yard runs when nothing is there don't exist and they are critical possessions. His inability to break tackles at the line of scrimmage also mean he is almost never getting the chance to make a move at the next level and get into space. He is not an everydown back from scrimmage. Max may not be Donald Brown, but he gets north and south real fast, low and carrying 210 pounds. Logic dictates to me that is a better compliment to McCombs than the wildcat.
Somebody called the goofy as play that got Chandler knocked out. I assume it was GDL. If any good can come out of that maybe it is that that play demonstrates how badly a change is needed with our OC.