The “Fab 5” label has not aged well. Castle was the only one that turned out to be fabulous. Ball is probably meeting expectations as a sophomore but Ross and Stew are not. Singare gets a pass I suppose. Certainly no comparison to the original Fab5
Castle was a top 15
Ball was a top 40
Stewart and Ross were in 70 to 100 range.
Singare was 100+
I would say both Ball and Castle met or exceeded expectations. Ball averaging 12+ points a game as sophomore is pretty good.
Guys in the 70 to 100 range often don’t pan out or take a while to develop. Hasaan Diarra was ranked in that range coming out of high school and it took him a few years to hit his stride.
You should not expect anything out of players who are not top 50 coming out of high school in their first 2 years. Sometimes you get lucky and they were underrated coming out of high school (eg Lamb, Napier, Boukknight), but for every player in that range who makes it, there are probably 5+ who don’t