The Mandalorian | The Boneyard

The Mandalorian

nelsonmuntz

nelsonmuntz

Point Center
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
47,018
Reaction Score
40,586
Disney+, ESPN+ and Hulu are offering a pretty attractive bundle, so I got it. None of them were strong enough to get by themselves, but $12.99/month for all of them is worth it.

I really like the Mandalorian. Pascal is great, and the main character is not likable, but is interesting enough for you to stick through some bad stuff to see where this goes. First two episodes are strong, the plot line is interesting, and the side characters are interesting. If you love Star Wars, you are going to love the Mandalorian. If you just like, or even don't like Star Wars, you are still probably going to like the Mandalorian.

My only complaint is that the background music is just terrible. It is like a B adventure movie soundtrack, and I can't figure out why Disney, a studio known for its movie soundtracks, would let their next franchise offering, and the foundation for their streaming service, get released with such crappy background music.
 
The episodes have been too short so far. Some fun stuff, but leaves you wanting more. Hopefully we will start getting some longer episodes, especially since they are only releasing an episode a week.
 
I read a reviewer's defense of the score, which has a western flavor to it. I think it is incongruous with a sci-fi show, but I am willing to get it another chance.

Episodes are a little short. The benefit of TV is that they can take their time with the stories, so I hope they flush the characters out a little.
 
nelsonmuntz said:
I read a reviewer's defense of the score, which has a western flavor to it. I think it is incongruous with a sci-fi show, but I am willing to get it another chance.
Expand ...

I haven't seen The Mandalorian. This comment made me think of Firefly/Serenity, which was a sci fi Western and some of the score went hand in hand with that.
 
I fell asleep. I don’t think it is that good at this point.
 
nwhoopfan said:
I haven't seen The Mandalorian. This comment made me think of Firefly/Serenity, which was a sci fi Western and some of the score went hand in hand with that.
Expand ...
I stumbled onto this over the summer and I think you and I talked about it then. It is a surprisingly good series made with then unknown actors many of whom have gone on to be pretty well established. (Nathan Fillion, Morena Baccarin, Gina Torres and Alan Tudyk.) I think it only ran one season so it is an easy series to squeeze in when you are looking for something to watch.
 
.-.
nelsonmuntz said:
I read a reviewer's defense of the score, which has a western flavor to it. I think it is incongruous with a sci-fi show, but I am willing to get it another chance.

Episodes are a little short. The benefit of TV is that they can take their time with the stories, so I hope they flush the characters out a little.
Expand ...

No, go with your first instinct. The score sucked. It takes me away from the cinematography, not into it.

Unlike you, I like the main character. Manages to convey the proper world weariness of the character with few expressive techniques.
 
nelsonmuntz said:
I read a reviewer's defense of the score, which has a western flavor to it. I think it is incongruous with a sci-fi show, but I am willing to get it another chance.

Episodes are a little short. The benefit of TV is that they can take their time with the stories, so I hope they flush the characters out a little.
Expand ...
Have not watched, but heard there is a spaghetti western style to it. If so, Ennio Morricone's scores are some of the best ever, so sorry to hear this soundtrack is poor. Not sure if that's whats going on here or not.

Westworld (movie) was one of the first to combine the two genres.
 
intlzncster said:
No, go with your first instinct. The score sucked. It takes me away from the cinematography, not into it.

Unlike you, I like the main character. Manages to convey the proper world weariness of the character with few expressive techniques.
Expand ...

I like the main character in a Don Draper/Tony Soprano kind of way. I am pretty sure he is more villain than hero, and that is hard to pull off for a show. So far, so good though.
 
CL82 said:
I stumbled onto this over the summer and I think you and I talked about it then. It is a surprisingly good series made with then unknown actors many of whom have gone on to be pretty well established. (Nathan Fillion, Morena Baccarin, Gina Torres and Alan Tudyk.) I think it only ran one season so it is an easy series to squeeze in when you are looking for something to watch.
Expand ...
Firefly has quite a cult following. Awesome show. Up there with Freaks and Geeks for best show that was cancelled inexplicably after just one season.
 
.-.
FWIW, I watched the first Mandalorian last night and was surprised by it. It's definitely watchable with a ton of SW references in it. SW fans will like it. Ironically enough I did struggle to stay a wake toward the end, but I think that was more a function of busy week and late start than actual quality.

It does have a bit of the gritty, scratching out a living, feel of Firefly.
 
I enjoyed it greatly but I’m hopelessly biased. They pulled off a great season and introduced Ahsoka Tano (and hinted at Thrawn). Pretty seamless integration into the existing Star Wars universe. Sure, a few of the episodes were filler but overall they held things together fairly well.
 
Season 2 was phenomenal. The mention of Thrawn was a jaw dropper, and then what happened in the finale brought tears to my eyes.

Jon Favreau could light a kitten on fire in front of me and I'd shrug and say, I trust he knows what he's doing.
 
.-.
Ugh, my Disney+ ended and the only thing I was watching was the Mandolorian. so I gave it up. Sounds like it was just when the season got really good.
 
CL82 said:
Ugh, my Disney+ ended and the only thing I was watching was the Mandolorian. so I gave it up. Sounds like it was just when the season got really good.
Expand ...
Might not be a bad idea to hold off until they’re close to releasing the next series, ie last quarter 2021.
 
huskypantz said:
Might not be a bad idea to hold off until they’re close to releasing the next series, ie last quarter 2021.
Expand ...

There's talk that it will be Ahsoka in the summer of 2021, the Book of Boba Fett in the fall of 2021, followed by Mandalorian in the Winter of 2022 and then Kenobi in he Spring of 2022. Not sure where the rumored Cassian Ando nor the Rangers of the New Republic shows will hit not to mention the animated shows, tough bad Batch will be this Spring.
 
You can survive racist posts from a decade ago if you are a minor character, not one from a week ago as your second offense. I guarantee she won't be missed.
 
.-.
SubbaBub said:
You can survive racist posts from a decade ago if you are a minor character, not one from a week ago as your second offense. I guarantee she won't be missed.
Expand ...
She's maybe the 8-10th most intriguing character in the show. Mando is primo, followed by Grogu, Moff Gideon, Boba and a few others before she deserves mention.
 
I watched a handful of you tubers diving into this. It appears Disney has been very inconsistent in how they've handed out punishments or what they've not responded to at all. Draw your own conclusions. They are definitely taking some heat for this.
 
nwhoopfan said:
I watched a handful of you tubers diving into this. It appears Disney has been very inconsistent in how they've handed out punishments or what they've not responded to at all. Draw your own conclusions. They are definitely taking some heat for this.
Expand ...

Of coruse they are. Profit drives a lot of the desicions that any company makes. Anything that threatens the golden goose that the Mandolorian has become for Disney (maybe even their only golden goose due to Covid-19) will be taken more seriosuly than others. In addition, she was not the lead person on the show and had been warned about her social media habits before.
 
huskypantz said:
She's maybe the 8-10th most intriguing character in the show. Mando is primo, followed by Grogu, Moff Gideon, Boba and a few others before she deserves mention.
Expand ...

And easily replaced in the narrative. We haven't seen much of Carl Weathers, nor do we need to. Same with her. She's a minor character who is irrelevant to the story going forward. Mando meets some other hired gun on any of the many planets he visits. Heck, maybe one of the frog eggs grows up quickly and learns to shoot.
 
Anyone else think the lead sounds like Clint Eastwood?
 
Mr. Conehead said:
In most companies, employees get a warning and a well-defined letter stating do it again and one is terminated. She's an employee of Disney and if she was axed after her first warning, I could possible see the cancel culture issue. But, this was her second or possibly even third warning. Not much sympathy.
Expand ...

Except that what she did didn’t even warrant a warning, and other employees tweeted much much worse stuff with no action taken at all.
 
.-.
You must log in or register to reply here.

Forum statistics

Threads
168,640
Messages
4,587,436
Members
10,497
Latest member
Orlando Fos


Top Bottom