I’m with
@Cuango on this one, totally. And especially about Kim. She took over an impossible job — a very difficult fan base, an AD that cut the funding for WCBB after Pat retired, and the patchwork of Portal players she’d inherited from Kellie. She had a very good recruiting class this season. A couple more decent classes and she can free herself from the portal.
As for her pressing game style, even Geno said about it, that’s what you do when you don’t have a good roster. He says he did something similar in the early years. But the point is to escape the need for it. And I’d also say that she’s already backed off partially from the ‘hockey line’ business. You can see it in the boxscore clear as day. She only plays 8 really, and mostly it’s Cooper Spearman Barker and Pauldo. The problem for her is that the press is physically and mentally tiring for her own team as much as for her opponents. In this game, Tennessee looked spent from mid-3rd quarter on. By mid-4th they were toast.
I like Kim as a coach, plus I feel for her. Tennessee has become a toxic job to be a WBB coach. She needs to show success quickly to hold onto that job, and for all the flaws with her team, if she can hang on for three more years, I have a feeling she’ll have built something. And how can you not root for someone who takes over this job very pregnant and somehow keeps it all together. She is a very formidable person.
As Sun Tzu so famously said, "keep your friends close but your enemies closer", I keep a keen eye on Tennessee and I strongly disagree with both
@Cuango and
@Bone Dog on their assessments.
#1. This freshman class is ALL Caldwell and was highly touted.
#2. The advent of the "portal" now makes every year an opportunity for a coach to bring in "her players" and she did with Barker ($600-800K), Wolfenbarger ($100K) and Robertson ($100-200K) and last year with Spearman, Cooper, Latham and Whitehorn. So how are these NOT her players???
#3. The "system" only works with discipline that while initially it looks like mass chaos, there is supposed to be process behind all the efforts including quick thinking, passing, shooting or drives to the basket and/or kick outs to the open perimeter shooter. Tennessee is NOT adept at that last part of the "system". Because they only hear "hoist more 3 point shots" and "have more shots than your opponent", they neglect getting "good shots" by passing or dribble/drive penetration and kicking the ball out to an open shooter.
#4. The roster is littered with poor shooters that was known before the season. I am leaving the Freshman out of this discussion as they were largely unknown shooters at this next level of competition but as I had written, Robertson did two years at GW in the A-10, moved onto SMU and woeful team in the ACC. She led SMU in scoring last year at 18.5 pts per game but this came on .325 and .312 shooting percentages, which is ATROCIOUS. Only our most positive LV fan
@stwainfan felt her shooting would get better in a tougher conference which surprisingly it has but only to .335 and .318. Wolfenbarger was put at the end of the bench at LSU and has now been put at the end of the LV bench. Barker is at .457 and .324 which are mediocre as the teams star player. But the team as a whole is only .410 and .301 which is not good. The philosophy isn't terrible but better understanding on taking "better shots" vs. "any shot" needs to be understood. Their paltry assists of 274 vs. an uncanny 292 turnovers also belies the problem.
Mostly those on VolNation (a harsh cesspool of fans) despise this system and "hockey style line changes" as it prevents chemistry from developing. Caldwell also does not sit players for poor play.
By and large, I am not against the "system" but she needs to incorporate within a more structured approach. This team has a lot of great athletes but who are not knowledgeable team concept players as evidenced by their one on one play. That is solely on the coach and her staff.
Lastly, her post game pressers are atrocious. She never really accepts any blame on the loss and constantly criticizes the player. She has shown no ability to make adjustments in game or at half time. I do not think she will ever be successful to the standard that the Tennessee fans expect or what the University is implicitly asking by giving her all the NIL money and other AD support.
But as correctly pointed out, despite the VolNation protestations, Caldwell is only in year 2 of her contract, so barring a complete collapse and not making the NCAAT, she will be given more time. She better hope to retain this freshman class and bring in portal reinforcements.