OT: - Still Great, just different | Page 2 | The Boneyard

OT: Still Great, just different

James Bond!
Sean Connery . . . Daniel Craig

Sean Connery was the master of course but I really like Daniel Craig the best. The movies are very different today, more serious and less campy.
Disagree on The Office. It just wasn’t the same once Michael left and I lost interest. I loved that show.

DO agree with Daniel Craig. Sean Connery was the GOAT but Craig’s movies were solid. Everyone in between was meh although Goldeneye was one of my favorite video games of all time.
 
No band has ever pulled off the "new lead singer" better than AC/DC. Back in Black out of the shoot. Unreal. Both singers were incredible.
I'm a big fan of AC/DC but I always felt Brian Johnson had to work too hard to sing in that manner. It's probably not the case because if it were that difficult, he wouldn't have been able to do it for so long. But it does look painful. Bon Scott had a very distinctive voice and I think Johnson tried to copy it.

The jeans though...

 
Blink 182
Tom DeLonge left and was replaced by Matt Skiba from Alkaline Trio from 2015-2022. It just wasn't Blink without Tom because they had such a unique sound. They still managed to put out some decent tunage but Mark Hoppus had to carry them. Tom returned and all is well again.

The trio of Mark Hoppus, Tom DeLonge and Travis Barker is just a lot of fun. Travis on the drums is awesome.

Early


Late
 
No band has ever pulled off the "new lead singer" better than AC/DC. Back in Black out of the shoot. Unreal. Both singers were incredible.
I would suggest that Genesis going to Collins was comparable. Far more commercially successful with Collins.
 
I'm a big fan of AC/DC but I always felt Brian Johnson had to work too hard to sing in that manner. It's probably not the case because if it were that difficult, he wouldn't have been able to do it for so long. But it does look painful. Bon Scott had a very distinctive voice and I think Johnson tried to copy it.

The jeans though...


Bon Scott was a Brian Johnson fan and wanted him to replace him.

I love them both but Bon had a great eye for talent, Brian Johnson is even better than Bon IMO.
 
.-.
Bon Scott was a Brian Johnson fan and wanted him to replace him.

I love them both but Bon had a great eye for talent, Brian Johnson is even better than Bon IMO.
I did not know that. so did Bon Scott pull over on the highway to hell and phone the boys "go get that bloke from Gordie"

This first vid is catchy



 
hq720.jpg
 
I did not know that. so did Bon Scott pull over on the highway to hell and phone the boys "go get that bloke from Gordie"

This first vid is catchy




Well I took some liberty saying he wanted him to replace him but the first the band heard about Brian Johnson was from Bon who was a fan.
 
Saw AC/DC from a box at MSG maybe 8-9 years ago with Axl filling in for an ailing Brian Johnson. Axl was absolutely amazing on vocals and refused to take center stage. He spent most of the time near the drum kit and let Angus lead. Really, really good show.
 
Well I took some liberty saying he wanted him to replace him but the first the band heard about Brian Johnson was from Bon who was a fan.
Yeah, I kinda got that. Where is the authority @August_West in this thread? I give those bands credit in the old days. They're out there performing and the audience is sitting there like they're at a funeral service. The Goodbye Love video.
 
Saw AC/DC from a box at MSG maybe 8-9 years ago with Axl filling in for an ailing Brian Johnson. Axl was absolutely amazing on vocals and refused to take center stage. He spent most of the time near the drum kit and let Angus lead. Really, really good show.
Some lead singers are so unique that bands simply couldn't replace them. GNR didn't lose Axl but he was certainly one of those lead singers.

As an aside, it reminds me of the 2012 HOF induction ceremony which included the Chili Peppers and the Beastie Boys. The Boys didn't perform because Adam Yauch - MCA had just passed away at age 47. These fellas filled in which I thought was Kool. I pasted where it kicks into high gear

Performance



Speech



Chili Peppers for good measure because they rock

Red Hot Chili Peppers – "Higher Ground" Live at 2012 Rock Hall Induction
 
.-.
This team is constantly being compared to last years team, which got compared to 23 which was compared to some Calhoun teams, etc... All those teams are different.
Here's a game to give us a little perspective.

Choose from these categories:
1) tv shows/movies
2) bands
3) sports teams

Where some seemingly drastic changing of the guard actually led to either no change in quality/or an upgrade.

Me? I prefer cheers with Rebecca and Woody. Sorry Diane and Coach.
The ratings for Cheers definitely dipped the year after Shelly Long left the show.
 
We got a little derailed here and I think this post qualifies. Keeping on the topic of replacements.

I am by no means a fan of this group, but Drew Bledsoe was replaced by a guy who turned out to have a pretty good career.
I'd actually thought in that direction after I re-redirected from TV shows to bands, but I haven't followed football closely in too long to recall if Montana & Young, or Favre & Rodgers were directly consecutive, after my first football memories were Connelly to Tittle.There are probably more (Sayers->Payton?), but, again, I didn't want to start looking things up, and I'd decided that Lowell George was where I'd draw the line on bands, not mentioning Duane Allman, or making obscure reference to the Butts Band, or dismissing the Foo Fighters, or wondering about Dave Alvin before the Blasters, bands populated with Modern Lovers alums, and way too many permutations across way too much cultural terrain.
 
I’ll throw in John Ritter and Tim Allen for funny men. Big Genesis fan and prefer the earlier proggy stuff but I’m not sure is because of Gabriel so much as the music. Although Mama was my fav song for awhile, I gravitate towards Firth of Fifth and Suppers Ready a lot. For another proggy band, I’d say Rutsey —> Neil Peart worked out pretty well for Rush.
 
I always trusted Bryan Ferry and Manzanera to make great records. I'm glad Richard Hell and ENO left or we'd never have their solo stuff. Tosh needed his own band, The Move sound nothing like Secret messages ELO but both these bookends and everything in between is classic. And...Representing the Mambo happens to be my 2nd favorite feat record (my favorite: Little Feat-the first one)

Thx for letting me talk about this stuff (I can't with a straight face pretend that Keith and Mick aren't the Rolling Stones)
Unexpected and most enjoyable response.

The 1972-74 Feats trio of releases is my favorite, same time period, applying as well for Stevie Wonder and Steely Dan, come to think of it. Studio releases by the Stones dropped off after Exile, until Some Girls
 
.-.
Since Genesis and Peter Gabriel are repeated, this is a great montage video. Talk about hitting it out of the park, grand slam style, 7/4 rhythm

 
Unexpected and most enjoyable response.

The 1972-74 Feats trio of releases is my favorite, same time period, applying as well for Stevie Wonder and Steely Dan, come to think of it. Studio releases by the Stones dropped off after Exile, until Some Girls
Those 3 feat records are untouchable. Song for song untouchable. Great comparison to Stevie. FFF is my sleeper favorite stevie Album from that period.
I don't think steely dan made an average record until everything must go. Every Record is gem after gem. Gaucho and Royal Scam are my 2 favorites if I had to pick though.
I would've agreed about the stones until Blue&Lonesome. IMO it's one of the best late releases of any classic band. (David Crosby and Tom Petty later years records are top notch too)
 
Last edited:
I’ll throw in John Ritter and Tim Allen for funny men. Big Genesis fan and prefer the earlier proggy stuff but I’m not sure is because of Gabriel so much as the music. Although Mama was my fav song for awhile, I gravitate towards Firth of Fifth and Suppers Ready a lot. For another proggy band, I’d say Rutsey —> Neil Peart worked out pretty well for Rush.
Poor Rutsey. That first album is still a classic though, so good for him.
I say Supper's Ready is the second best prog song ever. Hearing Gabriel say "A flower??" is enough for it to qualify. (Close to the Edge holds the top spot in my heart)
 
When I saw the title of this thread I thought it was a slogan for a new consumer product. Like the failed marketing of New Coke in 1985.

 
Lots of obscure references into darker heavy metal with swapping of instrumentalists I could go through but hey

As a more accessible example, Robert Trujillo after Jason Newstead after Cliff Burton saw zero drop off in bass play for Metallica

And many many examples of drummers I could go over lol like Mangini after Portnoy for Dream Theater, Alan Cassidy after Shannon Lucas for Black Dahlia Murder…
 
Last edited:
.-.
Unexpected and most enjoyable response.

The 1972-74 Feats trio of releases is my favorite, same time period, applying as well for Stevie Wonder and Steely Dan, come to think of it. Studio releases by the Stones dropped off after Exile, until Some Girls
This is totally OT and maybe should be its own thread, but you got me thinking: What is the greatest year in music history? I say '73, but you could make great arguments for '67 and '71, as well. What say you, Boneyard?
 
I’ll throw in John Ritter and Tim Allen for funny men. Big Genesis fan and prefer the earlier proggy stuff but I’m not sure is because of Gabriel so much as the music. Although Mama was my fav song for awhile, I gravitate towards Firth of Fifth and Suppers Ready a lot. For another proggy band, I’d say Rutsey —> Neil Peart worked out pretty well for Rush.
John Ritter was good. Speaking of which:
Stanley and Helen Roper (Norman Fell and Audra Lindley) were replaced by Ralph Furley (Don Knotts)
Chrisy (Suzanne Somers) was replaced by Cindy (Jenilee Harrison) and Terri (Priscilla Barnes)

Charlie's Angels
Farrah replaced by Cheryl Ladd
They also added Shelley Hack and Tanya Roberts
Farrah was Farrah but Cheryl Ladd was a great addition.

Finally, the Stooges.
One simply does not replace Curly

The Drop Football GIF
 

Forum statistics

Threads
168,149
Messages
4,554,860
Members
10,438
Latest member
UConnheart


Top Bottom