So Carolina AD asking for Review of Foul. | The Boneyard

So Carolina AD asking for Review of Foul.

Oldbones

Hates Surprises
Joined
Dec 24, 2014
Messages
708
Reaction Score
3,360
Tanner wants final call of USC-Tennessee reviewed

If I'm Miss St, I now ask for review of the ending of their Game. :)
A very wise person suggested after the USA/Russia men's basketball debacle in 1972 that it is best to avoid playing a game so close that the zebras might be left in a position to decide who wins. UCONN WBB has gotten this down to a science.
 

Blueballer

Transhumanist Consultant
Joined
Aug 31, 2011
Messages
5,189
Reaction Score
15,778
A very wise person suggested after the USA/Russia men's basketball debacle in 1972 that it is best to avoid playing a game so close that the zebras might be left in a position to decide who wins. UCONN WBB has gotten this down to a science.

Absolutely Correct!
 
Joined
Jan 26, 2016
Messages
12,903
Reaction Score
46,363
I was amazed how calm Dawn was during that end of the game debacle.........usually she is not shy letting the refs know what's on her mind.....
 

Nuyoika

Destroyer of Baked Goods
Joined
Sep 22, 2014
Messages
1,607
Reaction Score
3,370
So should TN ask for a review of the play where Coates is seen slapping the ball with two feet out of bounds?
I saw that in real time but cant find it on the replay. Do you remember when that was?
 

Plebe

La verdad no peca pero incomoda
Joined
Feb 22, 2016
Messages
19,416
Reaction Score
69,885
I was amazed how calm Dawn was during that end of the game debacle....usually she is not shy letting the refs know what's on her mind.....

She wasn't all that calm. She didn't hide her displeasure when it was called, and when the buzzer sounded she yelled angrily at the ref who'd made the call before turning in the other direction for handshake duties.
 

triaddukefan

Tobacco Road Gastronomer
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
19,772
Reaction Score
60,610
The fans should ask the South Carolina AD for a review of his choice for a football coach

kermit.jpg
 
Joined
Apr 10, 2015
Messages
11,335
Reaction Score
25,045
To what end is the review?
I wondered the same thing. Game is over--refs walked out--the game is in the can.
It won't get any ref fired--refs are expected to make mistakes--like ever other occupation including brain surgeons--or senators.
Bias--throwing the game are legal issues--impossible to prove without someone walking in with a video/audio setting up the game give away.
I see no value to be gained.
 
Joined
Oct 21, 2016
Messages
2,443
Reaction Score
5,888
The fans should ask the South Carolina AD for a review of his choice for a football coach

View attachment 19297

I wouldn't be sipping too much tea if I was you because Duke football is NON EXSISTANT and Mushchamp did a heck of a job with a team made up of 75% sophomores and freshman and taking them to a bowl game. Even Dukes basketball team is a little questionable(Big fan of the men's team btw) without Coach K, and I think SC men's basketball team could take the Blue Devils.
 

triaddukefan

Tobacco Road Gastronomer
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
19,772
Reaction Score
60,610
I wouldn't be sipping too much tea if I was you because Duke football is NON EXSISTANT and Mushchamp did a heck of a job with a team made up of 75% sophomores and freshman and taking them to a bowl game. Even Dukes basketball team is a little questionable(Big fan of the men's team btw) without Coach K, and I think SC men's basketball team could take the Blue Devils.

No way possible. The SEC has one legit men's team.... and it resides in Lexington. Did you guys lose to Clemson?

As far as football goes.. its not that hard to go to a bowl game these days. Only need 6 wins.
 

JordyG

Stake in my pocket, Vlad to see you
Joined
Jan 21, 2016
Messages
13,103
Reaction Score
54,870
A very wise person suggested after the USA/Russia men's basketball debacle in 1972 that it is best to avoid playing a game so close that the zebras might be left in a position to decide who wins. UCONN WBB has gotten this down to a science.
I couldn't have said it better. I never have and never will complain about refs and their calls. 'Nuff said.
 
Joined
Jan 5, 2013
Messages
2,163
Reaction Score
11,925
Dawn Staley keeping Wilson on the bench for so long likely cost SC the game. She did not trust her star player to manage playing with 4 fouls as opposed to Geno telling Lou in the Florida State game when she told him "That's 4 fouls, 4 fouls!", and he said "that's your problem, not mine" and sent her back out there for the rest of the game :)
 
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
6,918
Reaction Score
27,194
My suspicion is that the AD has been inundated with calls & E-mails from fans and this is an attempt to placate them.

I've always felt that there has been a reluctance on the part of the decision makers to making any public suggestion of incompetence in the officiating of sports. The are a lot of calls in every game that could go either way, and plays that are 50-50 as to whether a foul should or should not be called. And it happens in most sports. But any admission of the subjective nature of officiating calls into question the validity of victory and since celebrating the winner of any sports event is a big part of whole thing any suggestion of corruption on the part of officials is frowned on, by both the administrators of the sport and by the media that covers it. There is a reason that pro football instituted the review rules after decades of stonewalling any suggestion that officials are in error in any significant degree. As I have said previously, I am a cynic by nature. I remember asking on some forum whether anyone believed that in the history of pro sports not one official had ever "thrown" a game. No one did. And my followup question was "Why, in all these decades, hasn't even one official been charged?" That was before the scandal in the NBA. My cynical suspicion is that there have been several cases of corruption on the part of officials but that they were quietly disposed of without any public disclosure. Even the NBA official's scandal was quickly disposed of and never again mentioned by the media.

I am quite sure their have been wcbb officials who have attempted to influence the outcome of a game.
 
Last edited:

SCGamecock

Carolina Sandlapper
Joined
Apr 12, 2015
Messages
3,077
Reaction Score
11,264
If the goal is to make sure the referees are properly evaluated then I'm ok with it.

That's the goal. Obviously the result of the game isn't in question. State could've done the same last week and I would've been fine with that as well. Refereeing in WCBB could be better across the board, not just in those two instances.
 

SCGamecock

Carolina Sandlapper
Joined
Apr 12, 2015
Messages
3,077
Reaction Score
11,264
She wasn't all that calm. She didn't hide her displeasure when it was called, and when the buzzer sounded she yelled angrily at the ref who'd made the call before turning in the other direction for handshake duties.

LOL.. I remember watching that live. I was amazed how quickly she changed demeanor.. it was literally a 180 degree change in demeanor over no more than a second.
 

Online statistics

Members online
355
Guests online
1,989
Total visitors
2,344

Forum statistics

Threads
158,976
Messages
4,176,046
Members
10,047
Latest member
Dixiedog


.
Top Bottom