Look, I like Bazz and all, but are we already starting to underrate what Kemba did after two years? In the 64-team era, he's in a conversation with Danny Manning and Carmelo Anthony for willing teams to titles, and neither of those guys won the conference tournament preceding it.
Bazz has had some pretty great clutch shots and OT performances, and it is fair to say he can match what Kemba did in the regular season (Wichita State, Michigan State, Texas, Villanova). But what Kemba did in the postseason under intense pressure takes it to another level. Not only did he earn a spot in forever's highlights against Pitt, but he put up 28 against Gtown, 33 and 13 boards against Cuse, had the pass to beat Lville, the stepback to beat Arizona, 36 against SDSU, 33 against Cincy (half our points), a tough 20 and 7 and 19 and 7 in the defensive battles with Arizona and Kentucky. The stat line doesn't look good against Butler, which is a shame storybook ending wise, but I thought he played his balls off and the team fell in line behind him, effort-wise.
We don't win the NC without Bazz, but truthfully, if you go by the "we're screwed if he goes down" theory of ranking the importance of everyone, it would have been Walker-Lamb-Oriakhi-Napier. Also moreso that the foul shots (which came after he turned the ball over and Kemba battled Kentucky's front line to tip the defensive rebound to him), the biggest thing he did was run the offense in the second half against Butler. He shot 1-6, but I think he played all 20 minutes in the second half as the point and even though he only had two assists, I feel like he got us sorted out. When Butler went zone, Napier picked it apart. Much like Kemba, the stat line doesn't reflect how important his contribution was that day.
The book on Kemba has been written, and Bazz has time left in his career to make that jump, but until he does, this argument is a non-starter. If Bazz leaves and doesn't get another postseason run at it, we can fairly say that he lost his chance to move into that stratosphere, but we can't say he would have.
As for FG percentages:
Freshman - Kemba 47.0, Bazz 37.0
Sophomore. - Kemba 40.4, Bazz 38.9
Junior - Kemba 42.8, Bazz 44.4