I think I need to separate 'scariest game' and 'game that made me scariest to be around.'
Scariest game- Albany 2006
I can understand why Gonzaga would be here, but my life at the time (junior in college [not Uconn]), was so busy that I didn't put as much energy into cbb. That whole tournament was one wild party in between classes and work and I was just one happy dude no matter what.
The Albany game was just atrocious. I remember my brain turning the corner and accepting that it would be the first 16 seed to win.
Game that made me the scariest to be around- Duke 2004
I just remember screaming pretty much the whole game- filled with rage. Of course, that made the victory probably #2 all time behind the 99 championship, but I have no idea how my dad and brother stayed in the same room with me!
It's funny, as scary as a bunch of the 2011 games were (SDSU, Zona, UK), I guess I was just enjoying the incredible ride and was much more calm throughout. I didn't have the lofty expectations for 2011 and 2014 that I had in 04, 06, or even 09.