You don’t think he’s been underwhelming? Sure if he has an unreal offseason he should be in the rotation. But if he’s competing for a starting spot? We are in trouble. One cause I dont Think he’s good enough and two it means Cole isn’t that good.
There was a great deal of hope for "how great Gaffney was going to be this year" and there may be some fear being expressed that he won't be the player we wanted him to be.