Results are in: Boneyard preseason top 25 | The Boneyard

Results are in: Boneyard preseason top 25

How frequently should we do the Boneyard Top 25 poll during the season?

  • Weekly

    Votes: 17 50.0%

  • Every 2 weeks

    Votes: 9 26.5%

  • Monthly

    Votes: 7 20.6%

  • Other (explain in comment)

    Votes: 1 2.9%
  • Total voters
    34
  • Poll closed .
Plebe

Plebe

La verdad no peca pero incomoda
Joined
Feb 22, 2016
Messages
20,031
Reaction Score
73,696
EDIT (11/8): Results of the frequency poll are in. It was extremely close, but we're going to make this a biweekly poll since a slight majority preferred a frequency less demanding than weekly. The next round of ballots will be due on Monday, Nov, 18 at 9 a.m. Eastern time.

EDIT (11/1): I've added a poll at the top of this thread to help us decide how frequently (if at all) we want to put out the BY Top 25 poll during the season.


1572445294837.png


Number of first-place votes shown in parentheses.

Also receiving votes (selected on at least two ballots):
Syracuse 34, Michigan State 28, South Dakota 26, South Dakota State 12, West Virginia 12, Tennessee 9, UCF 6.

The following teams were selected on only one ballot (shown here in alphabetical order):
Central Michigan, Duke, Florida, Gonzaga, Green Bay, Iowa State, LSU, Princeton, South Florida.
 
Last edited:
When I looked at the results, it seemed from my recollection that it was pretty close to the ESPN results so I decided to compare side by side and it seems they are very close with errors <= 2 slots across the top 25. I am guessing many may have used the ESPN results as a first estimate and tweaked as needed

1572448006333.png
 
Last edited:
Astutely observed by @eebmg , and indeed I was planning to make a follow-up post about that.

The release of the espnW poll did seem influential. I say this not because of the final results per se, but because of some noticeable differences in voting patterns before and after the Monday morning release of the espnW poll.

For example, Arizona was selected on only 2 of the 12 ballots submitted prior to release of the espnW poll, which has them listed at #19. That had them fairly deep on the "also receiving votes" category at the time. But they were then listed on each of the 9 ballots submitted from that point on, which propelled them up to #18 in our poll.

The opposite occurred with Arizona State, which was selected on 7 of the 12 pre-espnW ballots but on only 1 of the 9 post-espnW ballots. Sure enough, Arizona State was not in the espnW top 25.

It's only human nature to be influenced by the prominent polls, and this was why I wanted to collect ballots before the AP poll was released. Of course, I had no idea about the espnW preseason poll.
 
Last edited:
Plebe said:
It's only human nature to be influenced by the prominent polls, and this was why I wanted to collect ballots before the AP poll was released. Of course, I had no idea about the espnW preseason poll.
Expand ...
We'll have to compare the ESPNW to the AP. See how close they are.
 
I'm standing on an island thinking Texas A&M should be in top 5.
 
.-.
LoTrader said:
I'm standing on an island thinking Texas A&M should be in top 5.
Expand ...
#5 was the upper limit of their range, but not a severe outlier :)
 
.-.
Plebe said:
View attachment 47572

Number of first-place votes shown in parentheses.

Also receiving votes (selected on at least two ballots):
Syracuse 34, Michigan State 28, South Dakota 26, South Dakota State 12, West Virginia 12, Tennessee 9, UCF 6.

The following teams were selected on only one ballot (shown here in alphabetical order):
Central Michigan, Duke, Florida, Gonzaga, Green Bay, Iowa State, LSU, Princeton, South Florida.
Expand ...

Great stuff, Plebe. Thanks for doing this.
 
.-.
TerpWomenFan said:
Is this really a question??????
Expand ...
So you believe that Maryland is going to be better than UConn. I predict that they will lose at least 3 games in the Big 10, and if they play anyone in the Top 15 on the road in the Non Conference portion of their schedule add another loss.
 
.-.
MSGRET said:
So you believe that Maryland is going to be better than UConn. I predict that they will lose at least 3 games in the Big 10, and if they play anyone in the Top 15 on the road in the Non Conference portion of their schedule add another loss.
Expand ...
I think the original question suggested to me that Maryland should be ranked 10th or 15th. I think they are legit at #5 behind UConn. In 2014-15 Maryland ran the table in the Big 10. This team is better than that one.
 
I think that it’s clear that this Maryland team is the class of the Big 10, and we might expect some recent stalwarts to have down years in Iowa, Michigan, and Michigan State. The biggest threat might be Purdue or well....no one.
 
Looks to me the three polls are not that far apart from each other (sorry for your loss @triaddukefan ). All three polls have #1 Oregon, #2 Baylor and #10 Miss St.
 
.-.
You must log in or register to reply here.

Forum statistics

Threads
168,508
Messages
4,579,438
Members
10,489
Latest member
Djw06001


Top Bottom