8893
Curiouser
- Joined
- Aug 26, 2011
- Messages
- 29,848
- Reaction Score
- 96,456
Just saw this this afternoon. I am more than willing to suspend disbelief for the sake of a good movie but I’m kind of pissed.So... Yesterday. Light entertainment Couple of twists I wasn't expecting that worked. Well acted by the two leads. McKinnon was a bit over the top. Sheerhan was ok - not someone I follow, but it was a self-effacing role for him. They left one of the best jokes from the preview out of the final cut. Other things were also eliminated from collective memory, in no discernable pattern. Could've done more with the premise, but it worked nonetheless. Good date movie. Wife & I enjoyed it.
I get how a worldwide electrical event could have eliminated certain things, and I get how only a few people might not have been affected—guessing it was because he was in the air and not touching anything during the outage. I’m a little less clear on how physical objects that existed could have been removed, but I would have let that go. My issue is that I was expecting at least some explanation of the logic behind what was actually eliminated, which, by our count was: Beatles, Oasis, cigarettes, Coca-Cola and Harry Potter. And if we follow the logic that the Beatles never existing means John Lennon was still alive, doesn’t it follow that if Oasis never existed, Jack never plays “Wonderwall” to enchant Ellie?
How do you hint at the melody to “Something” during the Ellie and Jack scenes during the last hour and never feature or play the song?
Bonus points to Mrs. 8893 for noticing that the Brits were referring to miles, not kilometers.
How do you hint at the melody to “Something” during the Ellie and Jack scenes during the last hour and never feature or play the song?
Bonus points to Mrs. 8893 for noticing that the Brits were referring to miles, not kilometers.
Nonetheless, a decent watch. Just wouldn’t rush to see it in the theater.
Last edited: