Oh really who are these 2 five star recruits that you speak of? All I and the rest of the entire college basketball community know of are Hamilton{a bona fide 5 star recruit} and Purvis{ a 4 star transfer that averaged 8pts, 1assist, and 2 rbs and struggled in the 2nd half and eventually lost his job at NC ST}
Well you named one of the two and called him a bonafide 5 star recruit yourself. That would be Daniel Hamilton.
Rodney Purvis 4 star or 5 star?
Let's look at the three main recruiting services in 2012.
Rivals had him #12 and a 5 star.
Scout had him #18 and a 5 star.
ESPN had him #20 and a 4 star. #1 through #19 were 5 stars for ESPN, so he was quite literally the highest ranked 4 star and one position from being a 5 star on ESPN.
I'd say that he was a five star and it's being very disingenuous not to include him as one.
Now as for stats: Purvis averaged 8.3, 2.4, 1.3 in 25.5 minutes at 44/51/39
Just for fun:
#4 SG Archie Goodwin averaged 14.1, 4.6, 2.7in 31.8 minutes at 44/64/27
#3 SG Rasheed Sulaimon averaged 11.6, 3.4, 1.9 in 29.2 minutes 42/80/37
#2 SG Gary Harris averaged 12.9, 2.5, 1.4 in 29.7 minutes 46/76/41
#1 SG Marcus Smart averaged 15.4, 5.8, 4.2 in 33.5 minutes at 40/78/29
So yes, Purvis was below those four for raw production.
The rest of the SG's in 2012 in the top 100. I think you may be able to argue based on very basic statistics that Calhoun and Dunham outperformed Purvis, but I don't think you could really argue any other player.
#6 was Ricky Ledo so DNP
#7 was Omar Calhoun, you should be well acquainted with
#8 was Kaitin Reihnhart who transferred from UNLV after averaging 10, 2, 2.5 in 29.2 minutes on 36/89/35
#9 was Montay Brandon who averaged 3.9, 1.8, 1.4
#10 was D'Vauntes Smith-Rivera who averaged 8.9, 3 and 1.4
#11 was Jordan Price at 5.4, 1.8, .9
#12 was Gabe York at 2.4, .3, .6
#13 was Kellen Dunham at 9.5, 2.8, 1.1
#14 was Codi Miller-McIntyre at 8.1, 2.7, 2.6
#15 was Melvin Johnson at 6.9, 1.5, 1
#16 was Rapheal Davis at 5.7, 3.9, .9
#17 was Torian Graham DNP
Finally, Purvis lost his spot because of his FT shooting. It was a legitimate concern. He has a year to work on it. One would hope he improves.
http://espn.go.com/college-sports/basketball/recruiting/player/_/id/96908/rapheal-davis