[
You missed the point. There's a difference between making someone a primary target early in the recruiting process and trying to find the best guy available in the spring to fill a void. We pretty much had a choice between Brimah and an empty chair when we brought him in. Or at least not another big. The 2012-13 season showed us we had some potential for this year, but we had a huge weakness (rebounding/rim protection) and Brimah helped fill it (more so with rim protection). With Bazz-Giff-TO gone and DD-Boat considering it, we would have been remiss if we didn't try to find some sort of reinforcement with a scholarship open. Vonleh and Johnson were long since off the table.
Similarly, when we hit the spring of 2009, we were losing Price and Austrie, we had cut Wiggins loose the year before, and we had nobody projected to back up Kemba and Dyson other than Beverly, who hadn't panned out well at that point. We had three senior starters and a chance to be good on paper, but we were severely lacking backcourt depth. We had to find the best of what was out there and Smith was pretty much near the top of the slim pickings list. That one didn't work - but if we had decided that we learned our lesson and wouldn't reach for a recruit in the spring, we would have sat idly by while Brimah went somewhere else and we almost certainly wouldn't have won this year.