I was talking with Cat last night about this thread. After reading and thinking more, I have a few more jet-lagged thoughts:
I like Scaife's game. I'm not sure if she'll be top 5 yet, but she's good.
Canada better than Caldwell? Could be. Caldwell's name was the one on the top of my head yesterday.
I like Amber Orrange and Lily Thompson. Orrange could be top 10, for sure.
Re Samantha Logic--as Mr. Spock would say, "It's perfectly logical."
I didn't see enough of the other players last year to comment. I know Harrison improved a lot, Coates was good, etc. But it's interesting in that the 2014 class was really good and the 2015 class looks quite weak (though KML has always been a star and Kiah could be one). As noted, Alexis Jones and Diamond DeShields would be in the conversation--if they were eligible to play. I'm sure there will be some surprises out there--players who are vastly improved or newbies who are unusually ready for prime-time. It'll be interesting to see who they are. Reflecting my true blue colors, I'll throw out 2 names of players who have been overlooked and could really impress--Morgan Tuck and Gabby Williams.