1. I think language is important here. I never said Butler is "not that good"... what I said was that she's not the post player that UCONN needs and is accustomed to this year offensively. Because she's so static, it may lead to Geno changing his offense if she's to start at Center. I'm not a coach, so maybe Geno sees something in Butler that I don't see when I watch her at game speed. He's the one with her at practice not me, so if he decided to play Butler at Center next year then that doesn't necessarily mean he's "playing down"., it could mean he really sees potential in Butler that I'm currently not aware of. Butler is a traditional center, much like our own Alaina Coates. When I speak of offense in this case, pretend that I'm talking about the player positions. If Butler starts for UCONN next year then that offense is PROBABLY going to look more traditional than the one that currently starts for UCONN. We start a very traditional roster.. Baylor is another elite team that starts a very traditional roster. Maryland does as well. To me, a traditional offensive roster is PG, SG, SF, PF, C... currently, correct me if I'm wrong, but UCONN starts a PG (Jefferson), SG (nurse), SF (Samuelson, who's also a Wing and better ball handler than her height would suggest), W/PF (Stewart, who can really play anywhere) and Tuck (PF/C, who can also play outside at times). You see what I'm saying? That versatility in the 3-5 positions allows so much offensive creativity, you have players that can play all over the floor... they can literally switch positions within a play and it would still work flawlessly. If that starting lineup for next year comes from the group you gave me then you have CD (pg), KN (sg), KLS (sf), GW (an undersized but good PF in my eyes), and NC (I guess a W/PF?). So I guess that's still versatile... But my entire point in my original post was how you'd lose a lot of versatility at PF/C if you have Butler starting at Center next year because she's a traditional center. I also said, "unless she revamps her game"... for what it's worth..
2. I used Moriah Jefferson because she was also very highly ranked within her class. While Hartley was highly ranked as well, I don't recall her being a consensus top 5 player. Moriah Jefferson was (I think?). Crystal Dangerfield is. So that comparison made much more sense.
South Carolina fan, you are correct. You are not saying anything that I don't agree with. Nothing against any player on any team, they all are giving their best. Some have it and some don't but Wilson would foul Butler out in half a quarter. Good luck to your team.
3. No... but then again, who knows. I could be wrong, it won't be the first time. It's really difficult to determine how quickly a player, even a highly ranked player, is going to acclimate to college.
Wilson was a top recruit and while she did have a pretty good freshmen year, in my eyes the game didn't really come to her until this year. That doesn't take anything away from Wilson, she's still great, there's just obviously an adjustment period coming from high school/AAU and going to high level D1 college ball. Same for Dangerfield, she's very highly praised and if she comes in and doesn't win the starting spot it won't be because she's not good, it'll be because she's adjusting..