Randy got pounded by the same MAC team this year AND last year.
Randy Edsall, at UConn, lost one game to a MAC team in the seven years he coached at the Rent, on the road, and beat two MAC champs in bowl games that the other school could drive to. That's not an opinion. That's not a justification for losing one. That's simply a fact. Randy Edsall, in his time at UConn since moving to the Rent, lost (I believe without doing the homework) not one OOC game to a BCS team that wasn't bowl eligible that year. Again, unless I've gotten that wrong, that is just a fact.
In one year, Coach P has lost at home to a MAC team, and is 1-1 versus the MAC, and has lost two OOC games to BCS opponents that I'd be willing to bet aren't getting to 6-6. Making him 0-2 in those games.
Now, I'm not laying 100% of the blame for this year on P -- far from it -- and I'm not asking for him to be fired. But let me ask you a question -- honestly, you don't see a difference in those compared results? You believe that since we lost to Temple once that no one can be below FHCRE in any comparison? What am I missing?