I'm an admitted flip flopper on this one. I wanted him to stay and be successful. Then, a few weeks ago after one of the brutal losses, I gave up on him. Then, after a few wins I said what the heck. Then last night I wanted him gone. I have a feeling my flip flopping will continue and ultimately it doesn't matter what I want.
I would rather he was successful, turned this around, recruited a little better, coached better and got better results. Less roster turnover, that is what is really killing the team. They can't build any cohesion at all. The reason I would rather this happen is the alternative is pretty scary also.
Fire him. Find a new coach. Even a good one will have to deal with kids possibly transferring and possibly decommitting. It will take several seasons to get his troops lined up. There could very easily be several seasons just like we are having before he gets his roster straight.
After two more bad seasons will this board be lit up with threads to fire new coach? How much rope you going to give him? We never should have hired this guy. I always knew he was a bum! (will say the folks trumpeting his wonderfulness beforehand)
Flip flopping and nothing I can do about it either way, so I guess I'll just cheer and hope to see some development out of Carlton, Whaley and Polley and a few wins here and there. Whatever happens with the rest will happen whether I complain about it, defend it, post about it, whine about it, write the same thing over and over and over and over and over and over again in 60 threads about it anyway.