Did you live there in the 80s & 90s? If not, how would you know? In the 80s under Koch the City was decent. It became a hell hole in 4 years under Dinkens ('90-'94), and was resurrected by Gulliani ('94-'01). Bloomberg continued to maintain decency ('02-'13). It declined again under deBlasio ('14-'21), which has continued under Adams ('22 to now). I do not recall people regularly being pushed in front of subways when I lived there from '83 to '92. I visited the City frequently until I stopped going because of the filth I saw there in '17. Yes I live in AZ simply because of the relative cleanliness of the desert among many other reasons.