OT: Scotch thread | Page 7 | The Boneyard

OT: Scotch thread

Killed my Clonakilty/Stout Trooper bootle last week and killed my last Lagavulin 16 bottle tonight, finishing as I type.

I’ll be looking to find any more of the Clonakilty/Stout Trooper I can in the area before I look for anything else. I won’t restock the Lagavulin 16 until I can find it in the $70s or lower again.
 
Killed my Clonakilty/Stout Trooper bootle last week and killed my last Lagavulin 16 bottle tonight, finishing as I type.

I’ll be looking to find any more of the Clonakilty/Stout Trooper I can in the area before I look for anything else. I won’t restock the Lagavulin 16 until I can find it in the $70s or lower again.

Be glad you aren’t in PA. I just checked his prices and Laga 16 is $115. Insane. The Distiller’s Edition is cheaper.

 
Thanks. I saw it there and at a place in North Haven. Gonna try and grab it from the North Haven place because it‘s closer but I will buy up as many as I can find that are reasonably priced. I will give at least one as a Christmas gift this year. It is really in my sweet spot.
 
Thanks. I saw it there and at a place in North Haven. Gonna try and grab it from the North Haven place because it‘s closer but I will buy up as many as I can find that are reasonably priced. I will give at least one as a Christmas gift this year. It is really in my sweet spot.

I don’t think we get it here in MA. Would love to try it. Copper & Kings brandy does a really interesting line finished in beer casks. This one in Jacks Abby Barleywine casks was awesome.
 
Be glad you aren’t in PA. I just checked his prices and Laga 16 is $115. Insane. The Distiller’s Edition is cheaper.
Dang. I didn't realize it got that high. I've still got 1/3 bottle left from the two I got for my birthday in April. Back then it was $92, but my brother in CT got in on the sale at Total Wine. Anyway, looks like I'm gonna need a new peat monster.
 
Dang. I didn't realize it got that high. I've still got 1/3 bottle left from the two I got for my birthday in April. Back then it was $92, but my brother in CT got in on the sale at Total Wine. Anyway, looks like I'm gonna need a new peat monster.

You have the Laphroaig Cairdeas Triple Wood and the Fino Cask Cairdeas at $80. Both are very good.

But I’m serious about Fine Drams. Lagavulin 16 Whisky - Scotch Single Malt
 
.-.
You have the Laphroaig Cairdeas Triple Wood and the Fino Cask Cairdeas at $80. Both are very good.

But I’m serious about Fine Drams. Lagavulin 16 Whisky - Scotch Single Malt
Given that it appears the only scotch mentioned in this thread that's available through the PLCB is the Glenlivet Carribean Cask ($45), I'll be taking a look at that site next time I scrape together $250 that my wife doesn't know about ;-)
 
The Glenlivet Caribbean is rum cask unpeated and not very old. A little sweet and different. Better value than the Balvenie Caribbean cask, which costs twice as much. Better still try Glenlivet Fire & Cane, young rum cask but also partially peated.

Best option is to leave both of them in the store.
 
Best option is to leave both of them in the store.

Yes, agreed. But Fire & Cane is decent. His selection is so much worse than yours or mine.
 
Yes, agreed. But Fire & Cane is decent. His selection is so much worse than yours or mine.

If he has to buy one to see what the rum cask is about, the Glenlivet is probably the call. It’s in my ‘deck Scotch‘ collection with a few others. They’re the throw-aways you use when you’re sitting on the deck and just want to drink something. Pour it over an ice cube and then get the ice cube the hell out of there before the whole thing turns to a muddle.

The Fire & Cane....doesn’t matter wha they did with it before the smoke went in because that overwhelms everything. I can’t give it away.
 
@HuskyHawk - I get a Liquor.com email every night and tonight's was 11 Scotches to try, basically covering a number of brand extensions/new releases.
Was wondering if you were familiar with any and whether you'd recommend.

For calibration purposes, Laga is my "special occasion" bottle while Famous Grouse is my everyday, although at the moment I've also got a $25 bottle of Loch Lomond Original, which while not in my wheelhouse for single malts is actually pretty good, especially for the price.

If you look at the article under that one about the Japanese whiskey....I really like the Nikka Coffey Grain. (And the Nikka Coffey Malt.))
 
If he has to buy one to see what the rum cask is about, the Glenlivet is probably the call. It’s in my ‘deck Scotch‘ collection with a few others. They’re the throw-aways you use when you’re sitting on the deck and just want to drink something. Pour it over an ice cube and then get the ice cube the hell out of there before the whole thing turns to a muddle.

The Fire & Cane....doesn’t matter wha they did with it before the smoke went in because that overwhelms everything. I can’t give it away.

I'm not rebuying either of those for sure. Both are too sweet for me. Regular Glenlivet or Glenfiddich 12 is better as a deck Scotch. If you want rum taste, just buy rum. Loads of amazing rum out there and it is cheaper than Scotch.
 
.-.
I made one of worst impulse purchases this week. I went out to the PLCB store to get a handle of Grouse but they were out. While I was perusing the shelves I saw a bottle of Kavalan for $45. Being unfamiliar with Taiwanese whisky, I googled it and learned that the distiller was considered a master of the craft and won many awards. OK, sold, I'll give it a whirl. However, there was only the one expression on the shelf and I didn't drill down for a review on that bottle. Big mistake.

I bring it home, pour a finger, relax on the couch and take a sip. It was a full out assault on my senses. Lots of heat, some hard medicinal Laphroaig-ish notes, and some leather and tar were competing with the butterscotch and fruit. It was not an easy sip nor one I think I could get used to.

So I googled again, this time for "Kavalan select". I learned that there are now 2 kinds of "select" but my bottle pre-dates that fork in the road and my bottle was made not to be sipped, but to be mixed in cocktails.

I am not one to spend $45 on a mixing booze. Not to mention I found myself out of Drambuie and low on essentials for Rob Roys and Robby Burnses. So I had to go back to the store for stuff to make this scotch palatable. But I did make one hella Robt Burns last night, and the Kavalan did well with the absinthe and bitters.

That bottle is going to mock me for months.
 
I made one of worst impulse purchases this week. I went out to the PLCB store to get a handle of Grouse but they were out. While I was perusing the shelves I saw a bottle of Kavalan for $45. Being unfamiliar with Taiwanese whisky, I googled it and learned that the distiller was considered a master of the craft and won many awards. OK, sold, I'll give it a whirl. However, there was only the one expression on the shelf and I didn't drill down for a review on that bottle. Big mistake.

I bring it home, pour a finger, relax on the couch and take a sip. It was a full out assault on my senses. Lots of heat, some hard medicinal Laphroaig-ish notes, and some leather and tar were competing with the butterscotch and fruit. It was not an easy sip nor one I think I could get used to.

So I googled again, this time for "Kavalan select". I learned that there are now 2 kinds of "select" but my bottle pre-dates that fork in the road and my bottle was made not to be sipped, but to be mixed in cocktails.

I am not one to spend $45 on a mixing booze. Not to mention I found myself out of Drambuie and low on essentials for Rob Roys and Robby Burnses. So I had to go back to the store for stuff to make this scotch palatable. But I did make one hella Robt Burns last night, and the Kavalan did well with the absinthe and bitters.

That bottle is going to mock me for months.

The Kavalan I've had has been good, but it wasn't "select", which I've never seen. Even the good bottles of it is an assault on your senses. It is designed to be. Amrut is much better made stuff, and would be closer to what most Scotch drinkers would appreciate.
 
The Kavalan I've had has been good, but it wasn't "select", which I've never seen. Even the good bottles of it is an assault on your senses. It is designed to be. Amrut is much better made stuff, and would be closer to what most Scotch drinkers would appreciate.
Amrut is special order only here in PA. So that $70 bottle of the 92 proof would end up costing me more than Lagavulin.

The heat of the Kavalan Select straight up is disturbing. Like a cheap brandy heat.
 
Amrut is special order only here in PA. So that $70 bottle of the 92 proof would end up costing me more than Lagavulin.

The heat of the Kavalan Select straight up is disturbing. Like a cheap brandy heat.

That's strange at 40%. I've had the cask strength solist stuff and it wasn't all that hot. It could be that it is just really young. Even the expensive Kavalan is young because it ages so rapidly there.
 
.-.
I never pour out the little bit of extra absinthe from coating my Sazerac glass.

We do need to get you some Scotch to get through the covid winter in Pittsburgh.
 
Not a scotch guy at all...I'm a bourbon drinker...but..

A friend gave me a bottle of Tomatin 18 year old...I take a sip, with ice, every now and again....I like it better than my Laphroaig kept for company.
 
Chivas Regal Royal Salute. A real post Thanksgiving meal treat.
 
Have we discussed at all why scotch prices have gone through the roof the past 4-5 years? Is it a cost to produce issue or more than demand has increased to the point where they can get inflated prices? I used to pay $50 in FL five years ago for McCallan 12, locally here it’s $90! What happened?
 
Have we discussed at all why scotch prices have gone through the roof the past 4-5 years? Is it a cost to produce issue or more than demand has increased to the point where they can get inflated prices? I used to pay $50 in FL five years ago for McCallan 12, locally here it’s $90! What happened?

Macallan has very high demand. Like Lagavulin. Tariffs are also hitting. But the tariffs affect the stuff that sells fastest, like Mac 12 and Lagavulin 16. Suggest branching out. There is better stuff that won’t break the bank.
 
Yeah. I picked up a 12 year Glenmorangie yesterday for $59, very solid. But even stuff like Glenfiddich that I used to pay as low as $26 for is $60 or more here. Nothing compares to scotch though in my opinion.
 
.-.
Yeah. I picked up a 12 year Glenmorangie yesterday for $59, very solid. But even stuff like Glenfiddich that I used to pay as low as $26 for is $60 or more here. Nothing compares to scotch though in my opinion.

Wow. You’ve got high prices. Normal Glenmorangie 12 is about $40 here and Glenfiddich and GlenlIvet about $48. I can still find Talisker 10, Lagavulin 8 for $40. Oban Little Bay is a decent cheap bottle as well.

You might consider ordering from Europe. I’m a fan of finedrams.com. Know the owner a little.
 
If you look at the article under that one about the Japanese whiskey....I really like the Nikka Coffey Grain.
I hope this is good. I just bought it on a whim out of disgust when I checked the price on Lagavulin 16 at my local and saw it was $99.
 
I made my first trip to Total Wine since the pandemic began and as expected Lagavulin 16 is back to $90 after that lovely surprise a year ago when it was $60. Thankfully I bought several bottles and I'm good for a while but I'm sure we'll never see it that low again. I wish I bought a dozen bottles.

I picked up a bottle of Bunnahabhain 12. I've never had it before but I need to work my way through all of the Islays and I never see Bunnahabhain in a bar. It's not a peat bomb by any means but it is surprisingly good. I've had a few glasses since I picked up the bottle and keep going back to it. At ~$50 it's something I'll keep stocked as it's a nice change from the usual Islays without straying too far (I know what I like, what can I say?). It's also good to have something solid to offer to scotch noobs who want to wet their beak without being scarred for life by jumping into something like Laphroaig.

Also, why on earth is Caol Ila 12 $70? It was one of my budget favorites at $40-$45 for a long time. I can't imagine Caol Ila is moving many bottles at that price point.

A regular rotation of Ardbeg 10, Laphroig Quarter Cask, Caol Ila 12, and Bunnabhain 12 is where I'd like to stay. Lagavulin 16 and Ardbeg Uigedail for special occasions.
 
Also, why on earth is Caol Ila 12 $70? It was one of my budget favorites at $40-$45 for a long time. I can't imagine Caol Ila is moving many bottles at that price point.
Yeah the Caol Ila 12 was $75 at the place I just saw the Lagavulin 16 for $99, and that pissed me off almost as much.

My problem is that I really like the Lagavulin 16 the best, so that's what I want. At this point I am ready to pay $80 for it--if I can find it that low.
 
It's frustrating how much and how quickly prices fluctuate. I'd like it if single malts would stop behaving like cryptocurrencies!
 
I hope this is good. I just bought it on a whim out of disgust when I checked the price on Lagavulin 16 at my local and saw it was $99.

Just go to Total Wine.

It varies store to store, but it’s never more than $90. (Usually 75-80 if I happen to be in New Jersey.)

For ten extra bucks, just do it.
 
.-.

Forum statistics

Threads
168,225
Messages
4,558,135
Members
10,443
Latest member
StatsMan


Top Bottom