OT: Giants | Page 49 | The Boneyard

OT: Giants

How is that a penalty BS, Brady was trying to tackle the guy you block him and thats a flag lol.
 
First, the Past and G-men put on an ugly football game. The Pats did less to lose that game and won.

Second, its clear that the NFL has no idea how to handle the new rule that challenges that coaches can appeal PI (or no PI) calls. The Pats DB had Tate's arm pinned well before the ball was thrown and the NFL offices in NYC still woudl not overrule the on-field officials. I saw a report that only 7 of 40 disputed PI calls have been overturned so far this season.
 
Mr. Conehead said:
First, the Past and G-men put on an ugly football game. The Pats did less to lose that game and won.

Second, its clear that the NFL has no idea how to handle the new rule that challenges that coaches can appeal PI (or no PI) calls. The Pats DB had Tate's arm pinned well before the ball was thrown and the NFL offices in NYC still woudl not overrule the on-field officials. I saw a report that only 7 of 40 disputed PI calls have been overturned so far this season.
Expand ...

Reviewing PIs is a dumb idea anyway. Only instituted because of how egregious the Saints one last year was. Officials blow calls sometimes. Let it happen.

DBs have the toughest job in football as it is.
 
Mr. Conehead said:
First, the Past and G-men put on an ugly football game. The Pats did less to lose that game and won.

Second, its clear that the NFL has no idea how to handle the new rule that challenges that coaches can appeal PI (or no PI) calls. The Pats DB had Tate's arm pinned well before the ball was thrown and the NFL offices in NYC still woudl not overrule the on-field officials. I saw a report that only 7 of 40 disputed PI calls have been overturned so far this season.
Expand ...
It is evidence that pass interference reviews will probably be reserved for plays as as blatant as the Rams/New Orleans debacle, but that is not the issue. The issue is the refs' interpretation was not communicated to the coaches, either directly or indirectly.

The moment I knew Jay Gruden was getting fired after the game was when he challenged the PI call vs the Patriots last week. He wasted a TO and challenge on a call that had zero chance of getting overturned.
 
Mr. Conehead said:
First, the Past and G-men put on an ugly football game. The Pats did less to lose that game and won.

Second, its clear that the NFL has no idea how to handle the new rule that challenges that coaches can appeal PI (or no PI) calls. The Pats DB had Tate's arm pinned well before the ball was thrown and the NFL offices in NYC still woudl not overrule the on-field officials. I saw a report that only 7 of 40 disputed PI calls have been overturned so far this season.
Expand ...
There has been a push from some in the NFL to eliminate Thursday night games because a majority of them end up being sloppy due to the short week. The 40 mph winds also didn't help last nights game. They are never going to eliminate the Thursday games because it would be a loss of revenue.
 
Can't wrap my head around the Leonard Williams trade. Don't hate it, but don't like it, not sure what to think.
 
we're a missed FG away from being 1-7 for the third consecutive season. trading away 2 picks for an 8 game loaner (unless DG has contract plans agreed with LW already) is par for the Gettlemen course. I guess we wait and see what happens with the contract before we truly know how bad of a deal this is for the Gmen.
 
Could be worse. I'm waiting for Stephen Ross to place an add in the Miami Herald asking local Miami residents if they would like to play for their Dolphins no experience required, just need to bring their own gear and show-up at Hard Rock a few hours before kickoff.

www.espn.com

Cardinals acquire RB Drake from Dolphins

The Cardinals have acquired running back Kenyan Drake from the Dolphins, the team announced Monday.
www.espn.com www.espn.com
 
The offensive line is beyond horrible. Dallas rushing 4 and constantly beating 5 OL's.
I'm going to assume they go defense in the 1st round and best OL with the 2 spot? And they will have to sign quality with their FA money on both sides of the ball.
 
OL is awful again, Jones seems like he turns it over 3x per week, and the defense just makes head-scratching errors all the time. What a great time to be a fan
 
Mr. Conehead said:
First, the Past and G-men put on an ugly football game. The Pats did less to lose that game and won.

Second, its clear that the NFL has no idea how to handle the new rule that challenges that coaches can appeal PI (or no PI) calls. The Pats DB had Tate's arm pinned well before the ball was thrown and the NFL offices in NYC still woudl not overrule the on-field officials. I saw a report that only 7 of 40 disputed PI calls have been overturned so far this season.
Expand ...
Because the rule was put in specifically to address a blatant, game changing call like the one in the NO / LA game. I think the league has made it clear that the rule isn't there to make every contested ball into PI. Nor should it.
 
Deadrody said:
Because the rule was put in specifically to address a blatant, game changing call like the one in the NO / LA game. I think the league has made it clear that the rule isn't there to make every contested ball into PI. Nor should it.
Expand ...
Which is fine in theory. But if that's the case then coaches should have been told that the only time it'll be changed is blatant game changing plays
 
navery12 said:
Which is fine in theory. But if that's the case then coaches should have been told that the only time it'll be changed is blatant game changing plays
Expand ...
this is the way all reviews should work.

It's way worse in the NHL.
 
shouldn't be able to challenge PI. Only at the booth's discretion. And they'll let the on field guys know if a grave injustice has been done.
 
Not until the season is over. Have to keep losing. Today was a good day for the franchise with their loss and all the other crappy teams winning.
 
They can probably win one more and still pick top 2!
 
Eli "very likely" starting vs the Eagles - Jones high ankle sprain

how sweet it would be for E to come in and BEAT PHILLY
 
Hope he does well to end his career the right way but still rooting for losses.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Online statistics

Members online
29
Guests online
1,079
Total visitors
1,108
Totals may include hidden visitors.

Share This Page

Forum statistics

Threads
163,972
Messages
4,377,054
Members
10,168
Latest member
CTFan142


.
..
Top Bottom