Those are fair points. But:
1. Our yards per carry was way, way down. Yes, we gained a lot of yards on the ground because we had to because we couldn't throw. But look at the YPC.
2. If you watched, there was far, far too high a percentage of plays last year where you would see one or even two OL standing around not finding someone to block and then just standing there. That was not a sight we were used to in the past because you found the guy closest to you and put a damn helmet on him.
I will respectfully disagree here. We were an entirely different offensive team in both run blocking and pass blocking in 2010, than we were in 2011. Many of the same players, entirely different way of doing things. Playing OL, was still the fundamental line up and enjoy beating the snot out of somebody for three hours a day, in relative obscurity, with the only time you get noticed if the ref throws a flag......but we did a lot different in 2011.
The most obvious,a nd frequent, standing around and not blocking somebody things happened on pass protections, not on running plays, and it's the biggest reason, why our OL led the nation in sacks allowed last year.
Not so much on running plays, biggest difficulty in running plays, as much as I love Lyle McCombs, he is one of my favorite players all time for what that kid gives up in his body to play the game the way he does...but the decrease in YPC? the ability to take the ball into a hole and regularly turn out 4 yards, instead of two, is a lot more about the RB, and what the offense is doing to the defense in general, than it is the OL run blocking. The holes and lanes were there in running the ball, we - like years past, regularly faced defenses that brought 8 guys in close to the line. When you're runnign into stacked defenses week in and week out, you need a RB that's going to make people miss to gain significant YPC.
I'd like to see what McCombs can do against a defense that's forced to play balanced against run/pass, rather than run heavy. Until any other back can demonstrate the ability to understand the pass protections, and pass protect, McCombs is our guy in the backfield. And that's why I love the kid. By the end of 2011, he's 5'8' 175 in th the long mud spikes and full gear, and he's stadning in there and taking out pass rushers coming full on speed 1-1, that are twice his size, and holding his own.