OT: - Oil Tank Fill Whistle | Page 2 | The Boneyard
.

OT: Oil Tank Fill Whistle

No but I had an oil company fill my basement with 300 gallons of heating oil and the house doesn't heat with oil.
It happened in mid January and we are still in litigation.

What the hell…..

300 gallons of open spill - that is well into the six figures in remediation and fines.

In Westchester County, if we have a teaspoon of oil land in the catch basin designed to catch overflow and a county inspector sees it, it’s a minimum of $7,500. $7,500 for a “spill” that we clean with one sheet of paper towel.

300 gallons…we’d be in jail.
 
When the oil company is filling your tank an external whistle goes off saying the tank is filled.

If the whistle doesn't go off, the tank could be overfilled, or even worse - the tank could burst.


Has anybody here had to go through this with their oil tank? Replacing the whistle.

It’s not a big deal. They can usually be cleaned, but if you need to replace it, replace it.

Most reputable oil companies will not make a delivery if they notice the whistle is inoperative.
 
The house was built 130 years ago and converted to natural gas heat in 1968.
We bought the house in the early 80s and the inspector said that the oil tank was solid and didn't need to be removed. They pegged shut the inner spout at the bottom of the tank and painted the cap on the fill pipe red. Over the years the paint faded but nobody had ever tried to open it etc.

The oil company was supposed to deliver oil across the street but instead the driver delivered to our house. My wife came home and smelled oil. On our mailbox was the recept that said - we delivered oil here in error - please call us to discuss removal from your tank or discuss you keeping it at a discount. She walked down cellar and was met with a lake of red heating oil 6 inches deep. She called the oil company who asked if they need to come and empty the tank - she said it's not in the tank, it's floating on my cellar floor. He said "OH duckK - you better talk to the owner. The owner was there in about 10 minutes and DEP officials were there within 1/2 hour. When asked if I was coming home soon, my wife said he's on his way from a meeting in New Haven and he is irate. The owner left right away. It's been a nightmare. Insurance company will end up buying the house.

The weight of the oil forced the peg out of the lower spout and the oil flowed out of the tank.

The tank and exterior spout has now been removed!!!!!
How is there even any debate? They screwed up and cost you your home.

Were they able to clean it? I can't imagine how hard that would be to remediate.

What a nightmare! Really sorry this happened to you guys
 
When the oil company is filling your tank an external whistle goes off saying the tank is filled.

If the whistle doesn't go off, the tank could be overfilled, or even worse - the tank could burst.


Has anybody here had to go through this with their oil tank? Replacing the whistle.
Say what, now? Never heard of such a whistle.
 
The house was built 130 years ago and converted to natural gas heat in 1968.
We bought the house in the early 80s and the inspector said that the oil tank was solid and didn't need to be removed. They pegged shut the inner spout at the bottom of the tank and painted the cap on the fill pipe red. Over the years the paint faded but nobody had ever tried to open it etc.

The oil company was supposed to deliver oil across the street but instead the driver delivered to our house. My wife came home and smelled oil. On our mailbox was the recept that said - we delivered oil here in error - please call us to discuss removal from your tank or discuss you keeping it at a discount. She walked down cellar and was met with a lake of red heating oil 6 inches deep. She called the oil company who asked if they need to come and empty the tank - she said it's not in the tank, it's floating on my cellar floor. He said "OH duckK - you better talk to the owner. The owner was there in about 10 minutes and DEP officials were there within 1/2 hour. When asked if I was coming home soon, my wife said he's on his way from a meeting in New Haven and he is irate. The owner left right away. It's been a nightmare. Insurance company will end up buying the house.

The weight of the oil forced the peg out of the lower spout and the oil flowed out of the tank.

The tank and exterior spout has now been removed!!!!!
JC....that smell will never go away. I opened a bung hole once and wheeeeew!!
 
Last edited:
The house was built 130 years ago and converted to natural gas heat in 1968.
We bought the house in the early 80s and the inspector said that the oil tank was solid and didn't need to be removed. They pegged shut the inner spout at the bottom of the tank and painted the cap on the fill pipe red. Over the years the paint faded but nobody had ever tried to open it etc.

The oil company was supposed to deliver oil across the street but instead the driver delivered to our house. My wife came home and smelled oil. On our mailbox was the recept that said - we delivered oil here in error - please call us to discuss removal from your tank or discuss you keeping it at a discount. She walked down cellar and was met with a lake of red heating oil 6 inches deep. She called the oil company who asked if they need to come and empty the tank - she said it's not in the tank, it's floating on my cellar floor. He said "OH duckK - you better talk to the owner. The owner was there in about 10 minutes and DEP officials were there within 1/2 hour. When asked if I was coming home soon, my wife said he's on his way from a meeting in New Haven and he is irate. The owner left right away. It's been a nightmare. Insurance company will end up buying the house.

The weight of the oil forced the peg out of the lower spout and the oil flowed out of the tank.

The tank and exterior spout has now been removed!!!!!
This is a terrible story. I'm sorry you are dealing with this. I've heard it before too from other people. We switched to gas two years ago and thankfully had the tanks and spouts removed so it should be hard for them to make that mistake. I hope.
 
Situations like this are the reason laws are written. It would make sense that when a oil tank use is discontinued the oil company or gas contractor should have to remove the fill pipe and vent pipe as well as the tank or lock the fill tube in a better way than just red paint. In 2025 it's amazing that people's homes are put at risk by not doing so. On Cape Cod due to the drinking water coming from such a vulnerable aquifer people have to have double lined oil tanks and it is required to put one in a home if it is sold to prevent the type of leak one poster described. Just a terrible situation gtcam.
 

Online statistics

Members online
291
Guests online
3,679
Total visitors
3,970

Forum statistics

Threads
164,998
Messages
4,417,438
Members
10,244
Latest member
Follower50


.
..
Top Bottom