I don't think the reason for optimism has anything to do with filling MSG, that's kinda shallow
The reason for optimism is this move is a clear sign the B10 wants to improve exposure in NYC, and we can be very much part of that solution
The whole damn country has alum there so that's a mute point too, no traction in my world.
NYC is a pro town, it has no conference affiliation. But when St John's was a top tier program, one can argue NYC was a BEAST town. So I would suggest a highly successful local flavor would garner interest in the Big Apple. That's why I'm optimistic about our chances.
Right now, we're locked in a corner without many options so we're one of the last fruit to be picked from the tree. I suspect if either the ACC or B10 started to show interest, the other would too. RU was about cable boxes in NJ, Louisville could have been about having multiple other options like the B12 or SEC, so they got plucked earlier (there's no way they bring more revenue to any conference at any level. Our transitional phases may have hurt as well). Same can be said about Pitt & Cuse. Maybe our lawsuit hurt, maybe BC did, maybe Hathaway and PP were anchors because they sucked so bad. Maybe it was some convoluted combination thereof.
Let's just say the stars were "aligned" against us, but that will change.