NCAA approves flopping rule (among others) | Page 2 | The Boneyard

NCAA approves flopping rule (among others)

Joined
Apr 24, 2022
Messages
6,503
Reaction Score
38,708
I think if you apply the logic that the size of the impacted object isn't the sole variable in play, then it shouldn't be that hard. There's force applied to the object as well as the balance of that object. I like this rule change. I hope they expand on it. IMO, too may defenders, who are in legal guarding position, but retreating (not set) get called for blocks because the offensive players just bull dozes into them. Flops became more popular because defenders weren't getting these calls. They started "selling" or "exaggerating" their position. Summing up my mini rant....legal guarding position does not necessarily mean set...although many refs call it that way.
Good clarification @LwrcasefaN. I used to think of it as already being in the direct path, and a sign was being contacted “perpendicularly.” Your body didn’t have to be at right angles to the other player’s movement, but this might show that you weren’t merely sliding into position at the same time they got there. This would be a little like the moving screen distinction. Easier versions of an offensive foul to call are when the offensive players fends off to aggressively (the forearm shiver) or lowers the shoulder (the bulldozer).

But even when someone is in legal guarding position, not every contact should produce a whistle. Especially with the bigs in the paint, you might end up with a “bull in a china shop” effect. Minor contact has to be permissible. This is why I’d expect some difference in the way these are called in the paint and outside the paint.
 

Centerstream

Looking forward to this season
Joined
Mar 6, 2017
Messages
8,522
Reaction Score
33,254
I wonder how they will signal the digits 6-9. Maybe using the ASL signs for those numbers?
Maybe the ref will go to the scorer's table, like they already do, and tell them the player's number?????? and in the vast majority of fouls, the culprit is obvious.
 
Joined
Nov 24, 2011
Messages
7,518
Reaction Score
24,554
Good for the NCAA. I just hope that the flopping calls are consistent. Oh, who am I kidding, those flopping calls are going to be inconsistent. One thing that I dislike about watching college football, is when they are making the targeting call. What should be a targeting call, is not. And what is not a targeting call, is called. And don't let it be a Big game! Jeez. We will see how this all plays out.
 

JoePgh

Cranky pants and wise acre
Joined
Aug 30, 2011
Messages
3,756
Reaction Score
22,102
No one seems to have noticed the BIG change in the no-charging "arc", and the elimination of the rule about the "lower defensive box". These are highly significant changes.

Crunching down the size of the arc so that it only covers the space immediately under the basket means that any defender can assume a legal guarding position a foot away from the basket and take a charge. Defenders don't have to be nearly as quick and agile as they have had to be to make their defensive stand several feet from the basket to stay out of the arc. The rule change will probably cut down on the success of penetration-style offense, affecting small quick guards like Aubrey and K. K. Arnold especially. On the other hand, it will make it harder for defenders like Aaliyah and Ice to accumulate blocking fouls for having their heels inside the arc.

The lower defensive box was the subject of one and a half Boneyard threads when it became an issue during the UConn-Tennessee game. Now that controversy will no longer exist.
 
Joined
Jan 30, 2023
Messages
1,347
Reaction Score
5,168
Flopping shouldn't be called a foul period. The play should continue and if the player on the floor who flopped gets in the feet of the offensive player then it should be a foul. The problem with flopping isn't the flopping part, it is the officials call offensive fouls when they don't actually see the action.

I went to a few games last year and I was shocked at just how poor the officiating is as a whole. College is still pretty good but HS is a joke and that is where many future officials for college will come from. Unless a person flopped no foul was called and when they did flop they called it without seeing it.
 
Joined
Nov 7, 2021
Messages
76
Reaction Score
282
Flopping shouldn't be called a foul period. The play should continue and if the player on the floor who flopped gets in the feet of the offensive player then it should be a foul. The problem with flopping isn't the flopping part, it is the officials call offensive fouls when they don't actually see the action.

I went to a few games last year and I was shocked at just how poor the officiating is as a whole. College is still pretty good but HS is a joke and that is where many future officials for college will come from. Unless a person flopped no foul was called and when they did flop they called it without seeing it.
Agree; the officiating in women's college basketball is beyond horrible and getting worse, in my opinion. Hopefully, these changes will help, but I would like to see at least a continuation on the play before the foul is called.
 

FairView

Mad Man
Joined
Aug 28, 2011
Messages
2,336
Reaction Score
8,260
Major crisis at Notre Dame. Pray for them!
Given their reliance on getting to the line to win, Notre Dame has been granted special dispensation. It's not a Papal thing, it's more like being grandfathered in due to their significant investment in perfecting the flop in so many forms.

Does this mean they need to change the policy that only permits dependents of Dick Fosbury as the leprechaun mascot at women's games?
 
Joined
Jan 30, 2023
Messages
1,347
Reaction Score
5,168
Agree; the officiating in women's college basketball is beyond horrible and getting worse, in my opinion. Hopefully, these changes will help, but I would like to see at least a continuation on the play before the foul is called.
I don't think it is only on the women's side though. It seems like they let all kinds of holding and hacking go and then call a touch foul that has nothing to do with the play. It really makes the game frustrating to watch sometimes.
 
Joined
Feb 21, 2022
Messages
631
Reaction Score
4,579
I think to "flop" you have to hit the ground, so Nika's acting like she was hit by a 12 gauge is safe.
 

nwhoopfan

hopeless West Coast homer
Joined
Feb 16, 2017
Messages
30,361
Reaction Score
58,038
How is throwing her head back flopping if she doesn't hit the floor??
It's called a head flop. I've seen lots of players do it. You don't have to hit the floor to flop. Ionescu did it constantly when she was in college, not sure she's doing it anymore.
 
Joined
May 1, 2020
Messages
6,548
Reaction Score
19,373
I think to "flop" you have to hit the ground, so Nika's acting like she was hit by a 12 gauge is safe.
It's called a head flop. I've seen lots of players do it. You don't have to hit the floor to flop. Ionescu did it constantly when she was in college, not sure she's doing it anymore.

It's a move that's very common across NCAA basketball as a whole to convince officials to make the call on player control, however it's not only defenders who are guilty for it. Players on the offensive side of the ball do the same which should be looked at as well.

How many times have we all seen posts complaining about players "selling" the contact to draw a foul when driving? If we're going to talk about the defensive side, the offensive side should be noted as well.
 

nwhoopfan

hopeless West Coast homer
Joined
Feb 16, 2017
Messages
30,361
Reaction Score
58,038
It's a move that's very common across NCAA basketball as a whole to convince officials to make the call on player control, however it's not only defenders who are guilty for it. Players on the offensive side of the ball do the same which should be looked at as well.

How many times have we all seen posts complaining about players "selling" the contact to draw a foul when driving? If we're going to talk about the defensive side, the offensive side should be noted as well.
Absolutely. I was thinking of offensive players in regards to the head flop. Agreed, flopping occurs with both offensive and defensive players.
 
Joined
May 1, 2020
Messages
6,548
Reaction Score
19,373
Absolutely. I was thinking of offensive players in regards to the head flop. Agreed, flopping occurs with both offensive and defensive players.
I know. Just expanded on it a bit. Some think certain players are guilty of that head reaction when on defense when it really isn't just a select few.
 
Joined
Nov 16, 2015
Messages
530
Reaction Score
1,904
I wonder where flopping was first seen in sports…. Fútbol? I love watching them flop like fish out of water. It’s comical and ridiculous at the same time. “Dude, why are you holding your left leg when no one was on your left side? If anything, you should be holding your right leg!” Has anyone seen a 260lb flopper in the NBA?? :rolleyes::p:D
 
Joined
May 30, 2020
Messages
1,230
Reaction Score
4,253
I wonder where flopping was first seen in sports…. Fútbol? I love watching them flop like fish out of water. It’s comical and ridiculous at the same time. “Dude, why are you holding your left leg when no one was on your left side? If anything, you should be holding your right leg!” Has anyone seen a 260lb flopper in the NBA?? :rolleyes::p:D
By the way, where IS Bill Laimbeer these days?!?
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
2,333
Reaction Score
5,409
I dislike flopping as much as any other unsportsmanlike actions.

But I'm leery of getting highly fallible refs any more involved in the game than they already are.
I forsee even more griping about the refs and their influence on the outcomes of games.
 
Joined
Nov 13, 2013
Messages
4,465
Reaction Score
20,094
I wonder where flopping was first seen in sports…. Fútbol? I love watching them flop like fish out of water. It’s comical and ridiculous at the same time. “Dude, why are you holding your left leg when no one was on your left side? If anything, you should be holding your right leg!” Has anyone seen a 260lb flopper in the NBA?? :rolleyes::p:D
Yeah, 280 lb Joel Embiid of Philadelphia. James Harden is one of the two best but he's only about 230 lb.
 

KnightBridgeAZ

Grand Canyon Knight
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
5,327
Reaction Score
9,089
Maybe the ref will go to the scorer's table, like they already do, and tell them the player's number?????? and in the vast majority of fouls, the culprit is obvious.
No one seems to recognize that these numbers are signaled in the WNBA. The WNBA doesn't allow any number above 55, but you can wear 49, for example. Or 9.

Previously the NCAA ref signaled the numbers using 2 hands. I believe (but am not sure) that with the higher digits used, they simply signal the first digit and then the 2nd digit. Kind of like flashing the digits.
 
Joined
Feb 7, 2019
Messages
318
Reaction Score
945
Wonder if our 4 frosh who just announced their uniform numbers earlier this week will change them?
 
Joined
Apr 11, 2020
Messages
2,458
Reaction Score
10,209
How is throwing her head back flopping if she doesn't hit the floor??
Sometimes throwing your head back is to avoid or mitigate contact. A skill I'd like to see Caroline perfect.
 

sun

Joined
Dec 3, 2021
Messages
2,315
Reaction Score
6,131
They're calling the new delay of game rule the "Caitlin Clark Rule" in this 48 second video.

 

Online statistics

Members online
310
Guests online
1,935
Total visitors
2,245

Forum statistics

Threads
159,560
Messages
4,195,761
Members
10,066
Latest member
bardira


.
Top Bottom