i am drawing from what Coach has said over the years..I welcome comments on what I'm going to write here. I realize that Geno is a great coach with an outstanding record.
What I have never understood, however, is why Geno plays his starters almost the entire game. Not just when the roster is depleted, as we have currently, but regularly for years. I realize that he reportedly views playing time as a reward for quality of practice. However, that strategy also runs the risk of needless injuries to the starters in a game than would be the case if he would allow the bench players to play the last quarter of the game unless we are in a very close, competitive game. Even so, could the bench players not play at least seven or eight minutes of a game? I realize that a lot of our recent injuries didn't occur during a game, but would it not be a good idea to let the bench play for the last quarter, especially if the game isn't close at all. Last year I seem to recall our being ahead by around 35 points, yet one of the bench payers didn't get into the game until the fourth quarter 1:38 mark. Just letting the bench play the fourth quarter if possible would certainly reduce by 25% the likelihood of a starter getting injured needlessly with a huge lead.
Also, in a non-competitive game, given our long list of injuries, should our players be diving for loose balls? Is the risk worth it in a setting like that? In a playoff game, by all means dive, and always wear protective devices on their knees.
He is aspiring to reach a certain level of perfection in every game, irrespective of the score and how far we are ahead. He plays the players who have demonstrated in practice that they can do that. His expectations vary by player. So if a player can meet his expectations (for them), they get a chance to play.
As many have observed, practice is often harder than the games. So, in principle, players should be able to play 40 minutes. The “tiredness” you see is often more mental than physical. An alert mind knows to play within the limits of the body. Diving for a loose ball when it does not matter is unnecessary risk taking.
In summary, I believe you get to play when you are ready. When you do play, it should be with intent, intensity, and intelligence.