More injuries in WBB (merged) | Page 8 | The Boneyard

More injuries in WBB (merged)

BRS24

LisaG
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
3,821
Reaction Score
23,046
Coach Yo has a point about defenders sliding under players. We've seen this a lot this year.


"I do think that something has to be done with this whole block charge thing. It was unfortunate to see Last-Tear go down. There needs to be a rule and then people won't slide under people. I've seen it happen twice. If we're trying to protect players, then why don't we make the rule?
That was dangerous. She was trying to make a play. Right now the rule says no matter where you are on the floor, attempt to get up under someone and take a charge. Then she had to go out on a stretcher. So something has to be done with that rule.
It's simple. If we're trying to protect players, let's protect players. That's not the officials' fault. It's the rule that's wrong, all right?"
 

Bigboote

That's big-boo-TAY
Joined
Dec 16, 2016
Messages
6,722
Reaction Score
33,827
Yes it was a very reckless play by the Ole Miss player. She was running at absolute full speed and barreled into Poa like a train.

The trainers and medics, you had ONE JOB, don’t move a player who just had a head and possible neck injury!

I don’t put any of the blame on Angel Reese or Van Lith for trying to help her stand up because they are not trained professionals, but the way the trainers tried to make her walk off the court was shocking and made me sick to my stomach. They should have cut to commercial!
Agreed. If I had a teammate asking me to help her stand up, I'd help her up absent any glaring warning signs. Also, Reese was motioning for training/medical help before she ever helped Poa up. If they'd hightailed it over there, the players wouldn't even have had a chance to help her up.
 
Joined
May 1, 2020
Messages
5,133
Reaction Score
14,130
Coach Yo has a point about defenders sliding under players. We've seen this a lot this year.


"I do think that something has to be done with this whole block charge thing. It was unfortunate to see Last-Tear go down. There needs to be a rule and then people won't slide under people. I've seen it happen twice. If we're trying to protect players, then why don't we make the rule?
That was dangerous. She was trying to make a play. Right now the rule says no matter where you are on the floor, attempt to get up under someone and take a charge. Then she had to go out on a stretcher. So something has to be done with that rule.
It's simple. If we're trying to protect players, let's protect players. That's not the officials' fault. It's the rule that's wrong, all right?"
Something similar to allowing a shooter to land. That makes sense.

There was talk about the impact of the rule change. Here's one that was overlooked it seems.
 

BRS24

LisaG
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
3,821
Reaction Score
23,046
Something similar to allowing a shooter to land. That makes sense.

There was talk about the impact of the rule change. Here's one that was overlooked it seems.
Agree. I'm all for the block/charge call for screens, or if a player goes into a defender while dribbling. The challenge with not allowing undercuts is that it happens so fast, and how do you define it - after one foot is off the ground? Put the arc back in so when a player leaves their feet and is in the air, you cannot go underneath? Something else?
 
Joined
Mar 9, 2013
Messages
1,825
Reaction Score
5,555
Oh man, I didn't even realize that. That'd be a massive loss for UCONN. I hope she's okay for the NCAAs.
I mean at this point the season ended in January with Aubrey’s injury so it’s kinda whatever. Just hoping it’s not the last time we see Aaliyah in a UConn uniform and we get to see her in ga
Coach Yo has a point about defenders sliding under players. We've seen this a lot this year.


"I do think that something has to be done with this whole block charge thing. It was unfortunate to see Last-Tear go down. There needs to be a rule and then people won't slide under people. I've seen it happen twice. If we're trying to protect players, then why don't we make the rule?
That was dangerous. She was trying to make a play. Right now the rule says no matter where you are on the floor, attempt to get up under someone and take a charge. Then she had to go out on a stretcher. So something has to be done with that rule.
It's simple. If we're trying to protect players, let's protect players. That's not the officials' fault. It's the rule that's wrong, all right?"
but that’s not even what happened on this play. Her player charged through Poa who has been there waiting.
 
Joined
Nov 30, 2020
Messages
819
Reaction Score
2,675
I'm no rules expert, but I believe with the state of the game, officiating currently favors offenses, particularly guards, to recklessly attack the basket and force a foul to bail them out. I feel like a lot injuries occur from bad offensive playmaking getting rewarded. I don't know what rules could discourage it but I feel like rules need to be implemented that would discourage offensive recklessness.
 
Joined
Mar 21, 2021
Messages
2,674
Reaction Score
12,511
I'm no rules expert, but I believe with the state of the game, officiating currently favors offenses, particularly guards, to recklessly attack the basket and force a foul to bail them out. I feel like a lot injuries occur from bad offensive playmaking getting rewarded. I don't know what rules could discourage it but I feel like rules need to be implemented that would discourage offensive recklessness.
Too many guards allowed to push off or follow through (unnaturally) into the defender.
 

LETTERL

Pack Leader
Joined
Mar 22, 2014
Messages
3,982
Reaction Score
6,415
Madison Hayes hurt her knee in the first quarter of the ACCT Championship. Status unknown but she did not play again in the first half.
 
Joined
May 1, 2020
Messages
5,133
Reaction Score
14,130
I mean at this point the season ended in January with Aubrey’s injury so it’s kinda whatever. Just hoping it’s not the last time we see Aaliyah in a UConn uniform and we get to see her in ga

but that’s not even what happened on this play. Her player charged through Poa who has been there waiting.
If I recall the play correctly, Poa was below the circle. Last season, she likely wouldn't have been there because it would been a defensive block. This year, that area opening up has made the potential of these more likely.
 
Last edited:
Joined
May 1, 2020
Messages
5,133
Reaction Score
14,130
Agree. I'm all for the block/charge call for screens, or if a player goes into a defender while dribbling. The challenge with not allowing undercuts is that it happens so fast, and how do you define it - after one foot is off the ground? Put the arc back in so when a player leaves their feet and is in the air, you cannot go underneath? Something else?
Wasn't a fan of the arc being removed, but I'm also biased because I'm more used to and prefer FIBA rules. Maybe bring it back, but a tad closer to accommodate the preference of NCAA coaches? I don't know.
 
Joined
Dec 21, 2013
Messages
266
Reaction Score
1,692
Brianna Scott of Georgetown was injured in the last minutes of their game against Creighton today. Could be a knee injury. She was wailing in pain on the floor; very difficult to hear. The announcers cut to a commercial.

Could be a factor in UConn's game against Georgetown tomorrow if she isn't available to play.
 
Joined
Aug 2, 2015
Messages
3,990
Reaction Score
8,926
40 years ago, a charge was called like 5% of the time. Now it’s about 50%. I know that players are quicker now, but I don’t think they are THAT quicker.

I agree. I hate it.

It's really hurt the college game particularly.
 
Joined
Aug 2, 2015
Messages
3,990
Reaction Score
8,926
I'm no rules expert, but I believe with the state of the game, officiating currently favors offenses, particularly guards, to recklessly attack the basket and force a foul to bail them out. I feel like a lot injuries occur from bad offensive playmaking getting rewarded. I don't know what rules could discourage it but I feel like rules need to be implemented that would discourage offensive recklessness.

I think it's sort of the opposite.

Everyone coaches their defenders to seek out charges and officials have more and more rewarded it.

It's sort of hard now for a driving player to get a call as opposed to 1987.
 
Joined
Mar 2, 2024
Messages
395
Reaction Score
900
Brianna Scott of Georgetown was injured in the last minutes of their game against Creighton today. Could be a knee injury. She was wailing in pain on the floor; very difficult to hear. The announcers cut to a commercial.

Could be a factor in UConn's game against Georgetown tomorrow if she isn't available to play.
This is frightening. I had the misfortune of hearing PSU's Tay Valladay screeching in pain after suffering her career-ending knee injury six weeks ago. It's so gut-wrenching to hear and your heart just aches for the player. I just hope that her mom, Christy, didn't have to hear it from her daughter (but I'm guessing that she did, unfortunately).
 
Joined
Dec 21, 2013
Messages
266
Reaction Score
1,692
This is frightening. I had the misfortune of hearing PSU's Tay Valladay screeching in pain after suffering her career-ending knee injury six weeks ago. It's so gut-wrenching to hear and your heart just aches for the player. I just hope that her mom, Christy, didn't have to hear it from her daughter (but I'm guessing that she did, unfortunately).
You are absolutely right, it was gut-wrenching. Her teammates looked like they were having a difficult time dealing with it; one player held her hands over her eyes, she just couldn't look.

Her mom was there -- but that may be a blessing in disguise. She was allowed on the floor to help escort her daughter off the court; and I'm sure she'll be providing important moral support.
 
Joined
Sep 6, 2015
Messages
5,517
Reaction Score
29,025
Brianna Scott of Georgetown was injured in the last minutes of their game against Creighton today. Could be a knee injury. She was wailing in pain on the floor; very difficult to hear. The announcers cut to a commercial.

Could be a factor in UConn's game against Georgetown tomorrow if she isn't available to play.

She was the 2nd Hoyas player to go down with a knee injury
 
Joined
Dec 21, 2013
Messages
266
Reaction Score
1,692
She was the 2nd Hoyas player to go down with a knee injury
Wow, I didn't see the whole game, so I didn't know of any further injuries. That's a shame. I do know that it was another "physical" game; I hope that these injuries aren't the result of yet another game that referees let get away from them.
 

DefenseBB

Snark is always appreciated!
Joined
Nov 10, 2016
Messages
7,913
Reaction Score
28,741
Kudos to her on a great career and her accolades this season. While the hope for her and Virginia Tech was a return visit to the Fianl Four, she has been a great player and I wish her only the best in the next phase of her basketball career, where ever it leads.
On a side note, I suspect VPI will not make it out of the 1st two rounds they are hosting and that Kenny Brooks may be headed over to Lexington a week from now…
 

Online statistics

Members online
467
Guests online
3,725
Total visitors
4,192

Forum statistics

Threads
157,026
Messages
4,077,653
Members
9,972
Latest member
SeaDr


Top Bottom