Taking a team to a BCS game is pretty far. I don't know how much farther we could possibly go.
I'll support Coach P, but I don't think he's the right guy for the job even after a good showing today and I would much rather have had Edsall on the sidelines this year.
Edsall has had a much worse year than Coach P. Coach P had a decent year, when you take everything into account - even if UConn does not win next week. However, when you take into consideration what is involved when a new coach takes over (e.g. management style, new offensive and defensive systems, not having your own recruits, new coaches) I think it is way too early to judge either coach. In 3 0r 4 years we will be able to judge.