Dill would be a huge step towards a bounce back 2012, as it more than makes up for Jimmy Bennett not being back (and I'm assuming that, given the timing of the injury, even if he came back to Uconn for his 5th year he wouldn't be near 100% for the start of the season, but we have never heard anything officially on whether or not Bennett is trying to get on the field next year).
UConn Advantage - came in second in his original decision, so he obviously liked the coaches and school. His recruiting coach (Hughes) and position coach (Foley) are still at UConn so there remains a familiarity.
Rutgers Advantage - for a kid with one more year left he may be enticed by the perception of the team. Rutgers returns a bunch of players and will likely be projected to finish higher than UConn.
Equal - The need for an experienced OT. With Bennett gone there is certainly a spot available at UConn, and based on what Trevardo Williams did to the Rutgers OTs there is no doubt of a need there.
It would really suck to finish second for a second time.
Dill would definitely work right now.. Don't think Brodie would be on the depth chart just yet, but I still hope we him.. Redshirt him ( put some more beef on him ) and unleash him come the '13 season....