Think he’s the guy that gives us the best chance to win. If he’s matured it would be nice to have a guy that doesn’t feel like a temporary guy at QB for once
Based on what? Spring practice v. Krajewski or the 2 seconds they each played last year?
Beaudry is not even here yet and probably is the starter.
Think he’s the guy that gives us the best chance to win. If he’s matured it would be nice to have a guy
Beaudry is supposed to be very good. Washington and Karajewski are said to be skilled. I’d guess Edsall does Beaudry. He loves the safe pick. Beaudry slings it and has gotten accolades from lots of D-1 types. He’s considered the best QB in all of D2 by many.
I’d love to see Washington or Krajewski surprise us all, but I think Edsall goes with the older, more experienced guy. Seems like standard RE protocol.
More experienced guy? He’s only played one season in the last four years. I think Washington and Krajewski have more games and PT in their senior year of high school than Beaudry has in his entire D2 career. Also, it’s not MW or Steven Krajewski’s fault they got two seconds of PT. Edsall had opportunities to put either QB in numerous blowout games. Im not sold on this guy coming in here and taking over. I’m betting the starter is going to be Washington or Krajewski.
Exactly. No one knows who the starter is yet - Randy included. May the best man win, as it should be.All three will compete for the starting job. The best one will get it eventually.
Two years ago, Pindell was definitely going to be the starter... until about midway in the first game, and Shireffs demonstrated he was still the guy. Edsall is going to play the one that gives him the best chance to win, no matter what...
Exactly. No one knows who the starter is yet - Randy included. May the best man win, as it should be.
Let’s just hope he picks the right guy this year. If we are down 21 at the half, against Wagner, I don’t think Edsall will make a change. I believe if Lashlee wasn’t there Pindell would’ve stayed in the whole game.So HCRE2.0 had only 2 choices in QB to start the 2017 season and he picked the wrong guy. Seems like with 3 choices his chance of picking the right guy is no more than 1 in 3. Probably less than that since as a "former college level QB bench warmer" he values "managing the game" over actual QB skills.
Q
You’re not wrong about Washington, but there’s definitely a different mentality knowing you’re the starter vs. coming into a game in garbage time. He’ll have the benefit of working with the 1’s a lot more in the offseason, so hopefully that means less turnovers if he ends up being the starter.Washington looked like a turnover machine in his limited play last season. Hopefully he makes the leap. Based on Beaudry's injury history and limited playing experience, not sure where the high expectations are coming from.
I think it was exactly the opposite. Lash let loved Pinsell but Edsall made the change.Let’s just hope he picks the right guy this year. If we are down 21 at the half, against Wagner, I don’t think Edsall will make a change. I believe if Lashlee wasn’t there Pindell would’ve stayed in the whole game.
I bet part of the reason lashlee left is because he wanted pindell to be the guy and he was pissed when Randy yanked him for shirreffsLet’s just hope he picks the right guy this year. If we are down 21 at the half, against Wagner, I don’t think Edsall will make a change. I believe if Lashlee wasn’t there Pindell would’ve stayed in the whole game.
I bet part of the reason lashlee left is because he wanted pindell to be the guy and he was pissed when Randy yanked him for shirreffs
I bet part of the reason lashlee left is because he wanted pindell to be the guy and he was pissed when Randy yanked him for shirreffs
Well that too. But getting overruled game one couldn't have helpedhe left because he could see the roster sucked and staying was career suicide.
what do you think the turnover has been about for the last two years
I know that the best guy should win and play. I agree with this 100%. I just hope it's MW or Steven Krajewski. Both were exciting QB recruits. So far they have been out played by a transfer in Pindell (Steven Krajewski was a frosh so excused). Now they might get out played by a D2 transfer? That's sad on multiple levels. Either RE can't recruit or our development staff is terrible.All three will compete for the starting job. The best one will get it eventually.
Two years ago, Pindell was definitely going to be the starter... until about midway in the first game, and Shireffs demonstrated he was still the guy. Edsall is going to play the one that gives him the best chance to win, no matter what...
I disagree. When you get put into the game your mentality should be the same whether your the starter or on the third string. Especially at the QB position. You need to go into the game with the mindset you have a job to do and do it to the best of your ability. Your performance shouldn’t be dictated on where you fall in the pecking order. That’s not what makes a good leader.You’re not wrong about Washington, but there’s definitely a different mentality knowing you’re the starter vs. coming into a game in garbage time. He’ll have the benefit of working with the 1’s a lot more in the offseason, so hopefully that means less turnovers if he ends up being the starter.
I agree with all of that. I’m just saying it wouldn’t be the first time that a freshman didn’t look good in garbage time chances, but ended up being a decent quarterback. We’ll just have to wait and see.I disagree. When you get put into the game your mentality should be the same whether your the starter or on the third string. Especially at the QB position. You need to go into the game with the mindset you have a job to do and do it to the best of your ability. Your performance shouldn’t be dictated on where you fall in the pecking order. That’s not what makes a good leader.
I know that the best guy should win and play. I agree with this 100%. I just hope it's MW or Steven Krajewski. Both were exciting QB recruits. So far they have been out played by a transfer in Pindell (Steven Krajewski was a frosh so excused). Now they might get out played by a D2 transfer? That's sad on multiple levels. Either RE can't recruit or our development staff is terrible.
I'm pulling for one of our current guys. It's not a good look when you're constantly bringing in transfers or JUCOs to play instead. Granted, it's the recruited players fault if that has to happen.