Martin confirms that he hasn't done s*$# | Page 2 | The Boneyard

Martin confirms that he hasn't done s*$#

intlzncster said:
Yeah, me too. Not sure why people didn't like it that much. It was a difficult book to write, for sure, but I thought it came out alright.

Martin's biggest problem is he branched out with too many characters. Erase the Iron Island chapters, and if you must include new perspectives, include only single chapter perspectives that advance the plot in an appreciable fashion.
Expand ...

I agree - too many characters and plot-lines that never went anywhere, which wasted the reader's time. He would have been much better served writing it in the style of LOTR, with tons of characters, locations, but with much more efficiency and general sense of direction.
 
John said:
I agree - too many characters and plot-lines that never went anywhere, which wasted the reader's time. He would have been much better served writing it in the style of LOTR, with tons of characters, locations, but with much more efficiency and general sense of direction.
Expand ...

The huge backstory is what makes A Song of Ice and Fire interesting. I wouldn't have gotten 100 pages into the first book if it was another straight line story of good and evil. Martin being a lazy sack of spit is an entirely different issue.
 
nelsonmuntz said:
The huge backstory is what makes A Song of Ice and Fire interesting. I wouldn't have gotten 100 pages into the first book if it was another straight line story of good and evil. Martin being a lazy sack of spit is an entirely different issue.
Expand ...

I agree with you about the backstory; I also agree with John and intlzncster that Martin created too many characters and plotlines. I mean, the guy added so many more different points of view that he had to split a single timeline of events into two parallel books. If you need two decent sized books to advance one timeline, you've created too many characters and lost control a bit.

Then again, all of that would be forgivable if he wasn't a lazy sack of spit and spit the books out at a higher clip.
 
Spartacus said:
I agree with you about the backstory; I also agree with John and intlzncster that Martin created too many characters and plotlines. I mean, the guy added so many more different points of view that he had to split a single timeline of events into two parallel books. If you need two decent sized books to advance one timeline, you've created too many characters and lost control a bit.

Then again, all of that would be forgivable if he wasn't a lazy sack of spit and spit the books out at a higher clip.
Expand ...

I like back story too - I love LOTR, and hell, that trilogy is nothing but one huge back story. But yeah - Martin just did too many different branching streams (using a river anology), whereas Tolkien did one major river, just with a lot of eddies and currents, etc. Heck, does Marin even have a river???
 
.-.
nelsonmuntz said:
https://www.yahoo.com/tv/george-r-r-martin-am-130047030.html

Sounds like Martin is feeling a little guilty that Winds of Winter is still basically just an outline after seven years.
Expand ...

“I am not writing anything until I deliver WINDS OF WINTER. Teleplays, screenplays, short stories, introductions, forewords, nothing. And I’ve dropped all my editing projects but Wild Cards.”

Translation: I'm not doing anything else........except Wild Cards. Outside of Wild Cards, Winds will be my secondary main focus.

Honestly, he should have said (and done) this 6 years ago.
 
This book series is going right along with the Wheel of Time. Not sure if anyone every read that one here but it took so long the Author actually died during the process. I think it took 20+ years. I was able to finish high school, college, married with a kid, divorce , new wife in the amount of time it took that series to finish. By the end I only read it because I had invested so much time from before in it. I have a feeling this is going the same way, I think I started it in 98 or 99 with the Game of Thrones. I refuse to watch the tv show also.. I started the book I am going to finish with the book........ maybe.
 
mike012779 said:
I refuse to watch the tv show also.. I started the book I am going to finish with the book... maybe.
Expand ...

I'm of the same philosophy as you with this in general, but I gave in on the series for a couple reasons:

1. It's fun to be able to discuss the TV series in real time, both with people who've read the books and those who haven't. And the acting and production value is phenomenal.

2. As you say, Martin may not even finish. So I'm not waiting 10 years to watch a completed TV series.

3. The corollary to that is that a rough approximation to the ending will be out there in the cultural ether, if you will. It will be impossible for you to avoid it. So you won't really be spoiling any thing by watching the TV series.

4. It's fun. Why rob myself of fun for what is essentially a silly principle? Self imposed deprivation is not fun.
 
mike012779 said:
This book series is going right along with the Wheel of Time. Not sure if anyone every read that one here but it took so long the Author actually died during the process. I think it took 20+ years. I was able to finish high school, college, married with a kid, divorce , new wife in the amount of time it took that series to finish. By the end I only read it because I had invested so much time from before in it. I have a feeling this is going the same way, I think I started it in 98 or 99 with the Game of Thrones. I refuse to watch the tv show also.. I started the book I am going to finish with the book... maybe.
Expand ...

First, you have the best avatar on the board.

Second, I too went through hell with Jordan's Wheel of Time and also often make the comparison.

Third, the comparison is unfair to Jordan. Jordan at least published a new book every year or two during those twenty years. He didn't finish the series, but it wasn't for lack of writing. He lost control, rather than took advantage of his fans. And when he was diagnosed with a rare disease at a relatively young age, he thought of his fans and spent his last days finishing the final chapters of the series and leaving notes and an outline for another writer to pick up and fill in the gaps. Martin is, comparatively, a big fat .

Fourth, watch the series. HBO is to Martin what Brian Sanderson is t Jordan. It's giving us closure in a manner that's faithful to the original storyline. I might not even buy the new books when they come out. Of course, I will read them. Just thinking of getting a library card in protest. :)
 
.-.
I started reading the first book when the TV show was in between seasons 2 and 3. I realized that, book 1 followed season 1 pretty closely. Sure, I got a lot more backstory and detail into some things, but reading it just made me think back to the parts of the show where it happened. So I scrapped reading any more and just lived with the show.

Martin is now at the point where the show is going to be done waaaaaay before the books ever could. Is he going to lock himself in a room 20 hours a day, churning out pages now when it wouldn't matter and the show will give everyone "an end" before he could write one? Whether it's the same end is irrelevant, isn't it? I think he's resigned to just enjoying the cushy ride the last couple seasons of the show will afford him.

The show has made writing the end of the book something that just doesn't need to get done any time soon.
 
Deepster said:
I think he's resigned to just enjoying the cushy ride the last couple seasons of the show will afford him.
The show has made writing the end of the book something that just doesn't need to get done any time soon.
Expand ...

This really sucks. And unfortunately, it's true.

Feel bad for the dude who's waiting dutifully for the books to be done. The over/under is 10 years, and I'd be leery of taking the under. The odds of Martin going the way of Ed Stark before that are too damn high.
 
intlzncster said:
This really sucks. And unfortunately, it's true.

Feel bad for the dude who's waiting dutifully for the books to be done. The over/under is 10 years, and I'd be leery of taking the under. The odds of Martin going the way of Ed Stark before that are too damn high.
Expand ...

I would take the over, give you odds, and feel bad for taking advantage of you. Seriously (except for the feeling bad bit).
 
If I was George RR Martin and I was a) rich as f---, and b) constantly dealing with whining fans, I wouldn't write a blessed thing either.

I'd put out a four-page pamphlet in which everyone dies and a new character named Tonald Drump becomes king of everything. Then I'd head to the Caribbean with my money, a boatload of rum and just laugh my ass off every day until I died.
 
.-.
Fishy said:
If I was George RR Martin and I was a) rich as f---, and b) constantly dealing with whining fans, I wouldn't write a blessed thing either.

I'd put out a four-page pamphlet in which everyone dies and a new character named Tonald Drump becomes king of everything. Then I'd head to the Caribbean with my money, a boatload of rum and just laugh my ass off every day until I died.
Expand ...

Your imagination is stunted. It's basically called reality.
 
Fishy said:
If I was George RR Martin and I was a) rich as f---, and b) constantly dealing with whining fans, I wouldn't write a blessed thing either.

I'd put out a four-page pamphlet in which everyone dies and a new character named Tonald Drump becomes king of everything. Then I'd head to the Caribbean with my money, a boatload of rum and just laugh my ass off every day until I died.
Expand ...

I imagine his publisher is not that concerned. One of two things will happen: 1) Martin actually writes something and it sells millions of copies, or 2) Martin eats himself to death, and the publisher hires another writer to finish the series.
 
Martin could have made enough money on movies and TV to hire George Lucas to clean his toilets, and Martin can't get the 6th freaking book done 6 years later. Robert's Rebellion and the Targaryan invasion should have been blockbuster movies by now. Disney is going to make a feature length movie about stealing an architectural drawing of the Death Star that will gross $500 million. Imagine how many movies they could have squeezed out of GoT.
 
Forget about Fatso. I'm looking forward to the more important questions---whom will his estate choose to finish the series? Will the next books be better or really, really better than Fatso's latest contributions?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Forum statistics

Threads
168,639
Messages
4,587,288
Members
10,497
Latest member
Orlando Fos


Top Bottom