Overall, I agree. Reid is a good coach, a very good recruiter (though I think he relies on non-US talent too much, did the same at SCSU), and does have a competitive team year in and year out, which is hard to do in any sport. That said, the have been dominant in terms of possession and opportunities over the last few years; but, the team seems to have a mental block about getting the clutch goal. Since this has taken place across multiple recruiting classes, the Coaching staff has to share some of that responsibility. Since UConn won the Cup in 2000, the following has happened:
2001: 15-5-2, lost NCAA 1st Round playoffs in Storrs to Rutgers 2 - 1 (3OT)
2002: 17-6-0, lost NCAA Quarterfinals at College Park to Maryland, 3-0
2003: 9-8-4, lost NCAA 2nd Round playoffs at Queens to St. John’s 0-0 (PK’s)
2004: 12-8-3, lost NCAA 2nd Round playoffs at Chestnut Hill to BC, 1 - 0
2005: 16-3-2, lost NCAA 3rd Round playoffs at Akron to Akron, 3 - 3 (PK’s)
2006: 10-7-2, lost NCAA 1st Round playoffs in Storrs to Fairfield, 2-1
2007: 20-3-1, lost NCAA Quarterfinals in Storrs to Virginia Tech, 1-0 (UConn was a 3 seed, VT 11 seed)
2008: 11-5-6, lost NCAA 3rd Round playoffs at Omaha to Creighton, 2-1 (OT)
2009: 11-4-4, lost NCAA 1st Round playoffs at West Long Branch to Monmouth, 0 - 0 (PK’s)
2010: 12-2-6, lost NCAA 2nd Round playoffs in Storrs to Brown, 1 - 1 (PK’s)
2011: 19-3-3, lost NCAA Quarterfinals in Storrs to Charlotte, 1 - 1 (PK’s)
2012: 17-4-1, lost NCAA Quarterfinals in Storrs to Creighton, 1 - 0
So, 12 years in a row that UConn has been knocked they have only scored a total of 8 goals in these games, 3 came in one game (2005), resulting in an average of 0.67 goals per game, which does not win many games. Of the 12 losses, only one has been overwhelming (3 - 0 loss in Maryland in 2002), while 5 have been via PK’s, 2 in OT, and the rest (4) have been by 1 goal. I am not sure though which loss was more painful, the 2007 loss to VT at home of the 2011 loss to Charlotte at home in PK’s. Both teams should have made it to the Cup.
I do hope they turn it around this year though as I would love to take my son to the Cup in Philly this fall.
As a side note, just one slight disagreement. Indiana has the second most NCAA titles (8) after St. Louis (10), which is also not a tropical location, and I am pretty sure that Bloomington gets just as cold as Storrs does in the late fall.