Karaban v Knecht | The Boneyard

Karaban v Knecht

N

NJHusky

Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
3,571
Reaction Score
10,967
In watching the draft seems like analysis of Knecht is similar to Karaban (and not because of race).

I know our offense won’t feature Alex the way UT featured Knecht, but in reading the draft analysis, seemed eerily similar to Alex’s game.

Curious to get opinions
 
I think most would agree with you and say that AK is not the scorer DK is, but I think that they are similar in that they will be both be key pieces of nba teams for years to come. I think DK will have a bigger name because everybody notices a scorer.
 
Knecht is a MUCH better overall scorer. True 3 level scorer that can do it from everywhere, whereas Karaban picks his spots and has the higher BBIQ

There is no comparison. AK is a stretch big, Knecht is a scoring SG/SF. If Karaban could score like Knecht can, he’d be a lottery pick
 
NJHusky said:
In watching the draft seems like analysis of Knecht is similar to Karaban (and not because of race).

I know our offense won’t feature Alex the way UT featured Knecht, but in reading the draft analysis, seemed eerily similar to Alex’s game.

Curious to get opinions
Expand ...
I love me some Karaban. But this kid Knecht scored 40 in a NCAA game, 36 I think against Kentucky in the last game of the season. He averaged 21 ppg on the SEC. He shot over 40% from 3. Alex did not feature like this....that said, I think he will next year.
 
Not even close - Knecht can create and hit shots all over the floor, has a high quick release that he can get off quickly with touch. He can put the ball on the floor with his head up and create a shot. Knecht also has some hops and while not super twitchy, much twitchier than Alex. Alex needs space, has a slower, lower delivery and is primarily catch and shoot. This should be a year Alex works on a game that moves closer to what Knecht can do offensively.
 
Dutch Boyd said:
Love AK, but Dalton is far better and probably the best player in cbb last year. Surprised he fell is far as he did but being 23 already didn’t help.
Expand ...
I agree he may have been the best player in college basketball. However, Rick Barnes is no Dan Hurley just like he was no Jim Calhoun. His teams seem to underachieve when the pressure is on.
 
Thx folks. I asked the ? Because nba analysis said Knecht was not overly quick or athletic but you have to respect his shooting and could be a defensive liability
 
I can see the similarities in how they project as NBA players on a good playoff team.
 
I think Alex is better, not a one hit (year) wonder.

Alex can score, pass, handle, rebound and defend. And he's had better coaching, can make better reads, and won two titles and counting
 
Dutch Boyd said:
Love AK, but Dalton is far better and probably the best player in cbb last year. Surprised he fell is far as he did but being 23 already didn’t help.
Expand ...
Not sure about far better….
 
Lakers got the absolute steal of the draft. AK needs to put up some big numbers this year to get into the 1st round conversations. Draft will be much deeper next year.
 
willie99 said:
I think Alex is better, not a one hit (year) wonder.

Alex can score, pass, handle, rebound and defend. And he's had better coaching, can make better reads, and won two titles and counting
Expand ...
That's a hell of a take.
 
bendm said:
i dont see it. Knecht is going to play 2/3 in the NBA and AK will play 3/4. dalton is a much better ball handler and 3 level scorer. AK is a better rebounder and passer.
Expand ...
AK is a better defender too with his length.
 
Knecht plays like a slower rip Hamilton with a jumpshot on a good day like Ray Allen. Defense will be a concern. And can he get in the lane against nba athletes.

Alex improved his driving to the hoop tremendously last year. He often did not finish. He is smart and knows when to take advantage of slower 4s. His defense and cutting also improved.

It is a given that Alex is going to improve his game this summer. Looking forward to seeing the results.
 
willie99 said:
I think Alex is better, not a one hit (year) wonder.

Alex can score, pass, handle, rebound and defend. And he's had better coaching, can make better reads, and won two titles and counting
Expand ...
Willie its not illegal for other players to be better than ours. Its always been that way here. UConn has always been the 'collective".

Just saying, players can be better than ours, but there is no team better.
 
willie99 said:
I think Alex is better, not a one hit (year) wonder.

Alex can score, pass, handle, rebound and defend. And he's had better coaching, can make better reads, and won two titles and counting
Expand ...
Karaban is better under the basket especially on defense but Knecht is a far better offensive player, and is extremely difficult to guard. He is going to add a lot to the Lakers.
 
Biggest comparison is Karaban will be older compared to most other players in next year's draft.
And Karaban, like Knecht, is viewed as a high floor, low ceiling NBA player.
 
Knecht was not highly regarded out of high school. His college career included 1 year at junior college and 3 years at Northern Colorado before one magical shooting display season at TN.

He's 6'5", and his defense is lacking at best.

I'm sorry, there are huge question marks all over this resume. He fell out of the lottery and I was feeling bad for him still sitting there at 17. I'm not alone, I saw at least one scout had him no higher than 30, probably an early second round pick.

I wish him well, I hope he has a long and prosperous career, and I still think Alex is better. I'm happy to let time do it's thing. Time tends to be good to my arguments
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Online statistics

Members online
234
Guests online
1,959
Total visitors
2,193
Totals may include hidden visitors.

Share This Page

Forum statistics

Threads
164,000
Messages
4,378,071
Members
10,169
Latest member
ctfb19382


.
..
Top Bottom