People:
James's point DEFINITELY stands, even if he didn't do a super fact check on their actual DOBs. This part of the discussion gets us no closer to the truth about Brimah. The point stands--which is the important part--because RP is American and has played the game his whole life and took the conventional route to college ball.
Also, Mau brought up RP in a legitimate way, since it was meant (I think, Mau correct me if I'm wrong) as a comparison showing that this board as a whole is harder on Brimah than on other comparable guys on the team. Frankly, the fact that they just about the same age only makes that clearer.