Results do matter. All the national championships that happened under Wardes watch? They matter. Fixing RPI? It matters. Getting us through the NCAA ban? It mattered. And yeah Michigan did see all that and guess what? It mattered.
But keep going all in on “duh Diaco sucked” as if that carries the day.
I agree that it would be unfair to characterize his tenure as a failure based on one hire. Giving Diaco the extension was what really crippled us and that was Benedict's doing. Perhaps in hindsight you could question the hire, but it isn't as if there were a ton of enticing prospects knocking on the door (I'm pretty sure people here wanted Narduzzi, and it looks like he could be on shaky footing at Pitt after a promising start). I can't bring myself to fault an AD too much for his failure to resurrect an irrelevant program with limited growth potential.
There were rumors from credible sources that Shaka wanted the UConn job, meaning there's every reason to believe Warde played his role in smoothing the runway for a great hire there (at the time, he was probably a sexier name than Hurley is now). In that context, the one year contract he gave Ollie makes sense. Calhoun put him in an impossible spot where he was either marrying himself to an unproven coach or punting on another recruiting class (which we couldn't really afford to do given how thin our 2013 and 2014 classes were). He was going to take heat - and did - no matter how he handled that.
He struck me as a reasonable, charismatic guy in general, and because of that competence he probably made sense for a school like Michigan that sells itself. On the other hand, I really question his management of PR at UConn. He was as big an apologist as any when it came to the APR, yet it seemed to buy us no good will with the media and only cemented the narrative he should have been fighting, especially given the timing. Perception was a huge problem throughout his tenure, and while much of that was no fault of his own, he certainly didn't do much to rectify things. Waiting until "the first semester grades came out" to give Ollie a real contract really irked me, even if it might have been Herbst's idea. And fairly or unfairly, the Tom Jurich quote about UConn being "written in pen" will forever haunt his legacy. That was the single most pivotal moment in UConn history and he's not going to be on the right side of it.