Is the debate over who the greatest coach in college basketball is?

[Jaydumo20]

College Basketball Report is for the dumbest of the dumb. Great they put Hurley #1, that doesnt change that fact.


Hurley is in fact the best college hoops coach and 2nd place isnt close. The rug doctor? hahahahahahaha.

But no one should EVER give CBR ANY oxygen. They really are for the brain damaged.

#2 isn't close. That's a fact. Looking back on Kelvin winning coach of the year now looks like the Jethro Tull rock album of the year Grammy win.

*(note: I personally will take 'Crest of a Knave" over any Metallica record. But that's besides the point)

 

[CONN78SEJ]

Painter over Oats, Izzo, and Dutcher is hilarious.

Nate Oats is way better than #9, and I would drop Bill Self several spots.

 

[TheHorde]

Nate Oats is way better than #9, and I would drop Bill Self several spots.

I think Self is elite, but Oats is definitely a top 5 coach.

 

[FfldCntyFan]

#2 isn't close. That's a fact. Looking back on Kelvin winning coach of the year now looks like the Jethro Tull rock album of the year Grammy win.

*(note: I personally will take 'Crest of a Knave" over any Metallica record. But that's besides the point)

It was heavy metal album of the year (which is what caused the controversy). Ian Anderson stated they didn't attend because they thought the committee notified them of the nomination in error.

 

[Dove]

Doh!!

 

[B1GEast]

I would say Mark Few but a valid case can be made for Sampson.

I'm a big fan of Mark Few.

 

[navery12]

For reference, this is how they felt about Hurley 2 weeks before the first championship



And before that season, they just throw names at a wall for engagement

 

[CONN78SEJ]

I think Self is elite, but Oats is definitely a top 5 coach.

Kansas is where 4 and 5 stars go for a vacation.

 

[Dove]

Doh!! Oh yeah. Illinois.

 

[McLovin]

No Kim English? Then what have I been reading on the Boneyard for the past year?

He's a better coach than Scheyer at this point in his career, but he coaches a team nobody cares about so he has that working against him.

 

[NJHusky]

I would take Hurley but there is still a very reasonable case to say Self. The crazy thing on this list is Pope, what has he done to warrant inclusion in the top 50 let alone the top 25? He seems like a nice enough guy but he had one real decent season at BYU. The KY colored glasses are strong on this list

Remind me how many tourney games Pope won in his career?

 

[Hoophound]

If we lost Hurley, I wanted to go get Sean Miller. I think he’s the best coach without a natty and he’d get one at UConn. I don’t know where I’d put Miller and McDermott on the list, but both are very, very high.

 

[TheChamps990411]

Scheyer does not belong on this list

Yup. I find it hilarious with his long career Cal is at 18 lol! Everyones on to his mediocrity. Soon Arkansas fans will know too.

 

[shizzle787]

Self has won two national titles and won the Big 12 regular season like 15 straight years. The battle for #1 is between him and Hurley.

 

[Hoophound]

Self has won two national titles and won the Big 12 regular season like 15 straight years. The battle for #1 is between him and Hurley.

Self has earned a huge asterisk due to his gratuitous cheating.

 

[shizzle787]

Self has earned a huge asterisk due to his gratuitous cheating.

Everyone cheats. Only some get caught.

 

[F101Voodoo]

Shaka criminally underrated

If we go on results Hurley of course tops Shaka….. Shaka is very well likely a future very very good coach. Greatness is an unknown. There are few Woden’s, Calhoun, some would add few Szewshewshesski ( Duke Boy), Dean Smith, Rupp, Etc

 

[Hoophound]

Everyone cheats. Only some get caught.

No. There was a level of cheating going on pre-NIL that was excessive. There is no way for anyone to reasonably claim that the transgressions of Self, Miller, UNC, Duke and others were typical. They weren’t. They committed egregious violations that most programs did not commit, nor would they have gotten away with had they tried.

 

[That Guy]

In what universe is Mark Pope #23??? If we're going by potential, sure, have him that high. If we're actually going by results and accomplishments the guy doesn't even sniff the top 50. Having him above the likes of Shaka and Cronin is so insane that it honestly invalidates the whole list.

 

[aceboon]

Painter over Oats, Izzo, and Dutcher is hilarious.

Izzo has been underachieving with rosters loaded with top 75-100 kids, he's washed

 

[boog204]

What? Guy won a chip two years ago. 2 in his career. Who would you put over him? There’s Hurley and Self — and then a huge gap — and then everybody else

Agreed... He's won two championships, 4 final fours, 20 + wins (usually 25+) for 25 straight years (at three schools), and has a 77% career winning percentage. Sure, he's lost some wtf games along the way, has some shade to him, and had a great deal of talent, but he's in the upper echelon of all-time college coaches. Putting anyone except Dan Hurley ahead of him is ridiculous in my opinion.