If it were me my priorities would be campus, player development, originality, and fan base (not necessarily in that order). As somebody who wasn't 18 that long ago, originality is a big one...I want to be different. And if I don't like the uniform it's a no-go. There isn't really a school that checks all the boxes, but given the criteria, these are the schools I'd give a look to:
Illinois - As a kid watching college basketball the '05 Illinois team was the coolest thing ever. Their fan base is one of the best in the country even if it's been dormant during some mediocre seasons.
Temple - Love Philadelphia and like Fran Dunphy. It would be cool to play at a Big 5 school.
New Hampshire - Great campus, it would be unprecedented and get me a ton of attention (I like attention).
St. Johns - MSG, NYC, Chris Mullin, and, even in its current form, the Big East is a pull for me.
Rhode Island - I really like Hurley and the basketball environment up there.
If Buzz Williams was still at Marquette, I'd give them a hard look, too.
Not sure what it says about me - probably nothing good - but clearly I value the education aspect way less than some of you. Matter of fact, I'd probably go the other way...no way in hell do I go to Harvard or Stanford or Duke where I feel like everybody is smarter than me.