I think BL has a perfectly reasonable take here. There is no clear best alternative. He stays, he goes, whatever. Either of those are a crap-shoot in terms of which would yield better results. As coaches were being fired recently I put forth that it was possible (worth checking at least) that a clear upgrade who was let go might come here. AD needs to at least kick the tires on that. Can't decide on stay or go unless you understand your best alternatives.
That said, 19 kids in the transfer portal. Benedict's staff has to exit interview every one of them and get to the root of why they are going. If it is because they are tired or losing or don't play enough, ok fine. If it's Randy, then we may need to address whether he can be a head coach in 2020 and beyond. The AD must get that data to help decide.