"WE got our butts kicked by a very strong ND team. now, back to practice to get some things ironed out."Perhaps you could say exactly what you would expect him to say? In your own words of course. . .
No, your views are as valid as anyone else's but they are outliers of the general population so people will disagree with you. As long as you know you will be a voice of a small, unpopular group and are willing to engage others in a civil discussion of your views, we're good.If views like mine are not appropriate for this board, I won't post
I just heard Geno take equal responsibility for the loss after genuinely praising ND's team and individual players. I also liked how he gave Stef the credit she deserved for her game last night.No, your views are as valid as anyone else's but they are outliers of the general population so people will disagree with you. As long as you know you will be a voice of a small, unpopular group and are willing to engage others in a civil discussion of your views, we're good.
There's a certain set of poster behaviors that aren't "inappropriate" for this board but are, nonetheless, a turnoff for many other posters. These include:
1. Lecturing the board as a whole about its attitudes.
2. Implying that others here are hypocrites for their partisanship.
3. Pursuing an "I told you so" campaign after negative events.
4. "Threatening" to take one's ball and go home on account of imaginary censorship.
My unsolicited advice to all such people: State your views, positive or negative, and refrain from such fervent attention to the perceived attitudinal failings of other posters.
Your hypocrisy is another fan's logic.are you saying that it's all right to be hypocritical if it's due to your being partisan?
I'm saying whether it is or isn't "all right" in your view, you aren't going to change people's behavior in a partisan sports forum by demanding they meet your standards of even-handedness.are you saying that it's all right to be hypocritical if it's due to your being partisan?
GREAT post Chappy! We have been so spoiled over the years, we forget we are dealing with young people. It's really surprising that we've had so many teams that COULD and DID follow the game plans over the years. I still have faith in this group...there is a lot of talent on this team, and there is still time to pull things together. Love to be a fly on the wall at this week's practices.I am so tired of this crap. Geno is a straight shooter. He calls it like he sees it. He pointed out what he sees as the problem with this team. They don't listen. He takes ownership, sarcastic or otherwise, because he hasn't been able to get through to them. How dare Geno even think about holding his players accountable! He should just pat them on the back, say good try and we'll get 'em next time, just keep doing exactly what your are doing, it will all work out. They are only kids, after all.
Why are some of his teams so successful? How has he been able to coach his teams to 7 national championships, and make it look so simple even when they play teams with superior talent, at least on paper? Why do other teams not quite live up to Geno's, and the fans, lofty expectations? What is the variable that accounts for that difference? It isn't the coaching staff, the core of which has been in place for 27 years. It isn't the uniforms, the shoes, the basketball, the size and shape of the court, the rules of the game. Those are the constants.
The variable is the individual players. At the end of every season they lose players. At the beginning of the next season they gain new players. The dynamics of the team changes every single year. The players are individuals with different personalities that collectively form the team personality. Sometimes the pieces fit together seamlessly, and the team's collective personality is very driven with everyone on the same page, focused on the task at hand, everyone listens and understands exactly what they need to do, and collectively go out and do it. But sometimes the individual personalities of the players are not all on the same page, sometimes they don't focus or understand what is being asked of them. Sometimes it just doesn't work out the way everyone expects.
I struggle with understanding why people are so quick to blame Geno when the team personality isn't quite as efficient or effective as previous teams. He teaches, he guides, he develops, he gives each player the tools they can use to be successful. Only the players can use those tools. If they choose not to listen or choose not to follow the game plan why is it wrong to hold the players accountable? Geno can and should take responsibility for choosing not to guard McBride. He can and should take responsibility when his defensive plan ends up being the wrong choice. He can and should take responsibility for failing to adjust his game plan during the game. But to expect him to take responsibility for the players not following a drawn up play, for taking bad shots, for committing silly fouls or bad turnovers...I don't get that. I really don't.
This is a rebuilding year. We are doing just fine. Many of us expected this. I think some remembering our comments at the beginning of the year again would be a useful exercise.
As I've said many times, everybody is a hypocrite........in one way or another.Your hypocrisy is another fan's logic.
boon,
"i have not read in any of Geno's comments anything remotely sounding like the coaches also have to take some responsibility for what happened last night."
Geno did indeed toss himself under the bus. Apparently, he wanted to enjoy his under-carriage time in the company of these fine young players.
It is this assessing of blame on the players that appears to bother you and "lots of boneyarders" but is fine with me and lots of Boneyarders. If clear of all other issues, including those issues that are unknown to you & I, but know to the coaches, I might be able to find a way to agree with you, if I could be convinced that each and every one of them played to their own average or better abilities as displayed this season and last season....
Others have pointed out his "responsible for" statements.... sarcasm aside, his words on this are there to be found.... Overall, his statements seemed to be balanced, honest, and completely fair in his assessment as the disappointed coach.
Wrt, the second higlighted sentence::: he did not "throw all the blame on the players" he accepted responsibility for part of this failure.
Your Ol' Pal Boo
i don't have a problem with players being called out for not hustling and not listening . and i have no problem with geno , or any coach, doing that. what i want to hear from the coach in that situation , though, is something like," certain players are not hustling and not listening, and we've got to find a way to get through to them, because we haven't done a very good job at that". end of comments. blame spread all around. unfortunately,i find it very hard to cast the sarcasm aside, and hear real sincerity. maybe if he somehow could stop being a sarcastic wise-ass so much of the time, i would get better at taking him seriously. i would feel a whole lot better if i felt that he honestly felt like he'd done a lousy job in getting those players to listen. maybe he does, but when he says that" they won't listen to anybody ", it sounds to me like he's taking himself and the other coaches off the hook.
btw, i must say that off all the posters here, i usually find your comments quite measured, thoughtful, and very worthwhile to read. thanks for your efforts, Boo.
Boon,
If you wouldn't mind, I would love to hear your suggestion(s) on how to get someone to listen? What specifically should Geno do in order to do a better job at getting them to listen and follow his instructions and game plan?
And just to level set, my interpretation of what Geno means by "listen" is not just hearing his words. It is digesting what he says, understanding what he is saying, and then following through with what he has said by doing it.
I know of no fool-proof way Geno can get the players to follow his instructions. But you seem to think there is a way, so please do share your thoughts. I am not trying to be sarcastic. I am truly curious.
Boo,
that makes two of us who don't know, though it does bring to mind the story about the farmer who was very good at getting mules to do what he wanted them to do. something about a 2 by 4 piece of wood. that said, wouldn't you think,though, that a hall of fame coach and 3 assistants, after working with these players for many months, would know ? it can't be easy, especially with the frosh, but it seems like certain basic things, like whether they're playing zone or man-to-man when they go back on the court after a timeout, shouldn't be that hard to communicate. i say that because someone here said that it looked like there was a mix-up in that regard after one of the timeouts late in the ND game. how does that happen?
I'm not Boo, but I will answer your question.
It happens when kids don't listen and follow direction. I still don't get how that is Geno's fault?