I have a feeling Saniya will end up starting over MoJeff. | Page 4 | The Boneyard

I have a feeling Saniya will end up starting over MoJeff.

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'll let you off the hook. You have been wrong the entire time about it. No comment about the initiation point with KML?

I'm done. You will NEVER admit when you are wrong, even when given video evidence. So, have the last word.
It isn't about being right or wrong it is about finding a way to express the ideas involved with clarity.

The video evidence is what it is and there is nothing in it that changes what I am saying about the shot. Everything I have said is what I see in the video. We are talking about different aspects of the shot.

Why is a lay up not a jump shot under your definition? After one jumps.
 
Last edited:
Here is video of Maya teaching the perfect shot, the Jump Shot. This is the moment I am attempting to describe and is the formal use of Jump Shot. Shot from this position over the fore brow and extending straight up and out on trajectory towards the basket. Anything before this moment is variable and unimportant but only from this position and at the apex of the jump is the classic Jump Shot almost unblockable. http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=3tpJs7Msqvs

 
Last edited:
I hate when I say I am done, when I'm not....lol.

Stop the presses, Moore has a perfect jump shot. No, not a capital J (something you made up) but the classic jumper.

She initiates her shot from the hip. You said it has to start at the chin. Now she does bring the ball to her face and then extend her arms had wow....what form.

Chong does not have that classic jump shot. But it's a jump shot. You first called it a set shot, then a hybrid and now, I have no idea what you think she does.

Thanks for the video. I always love watching Moore shoot.
 
A late arrival to this discussion

We can all agree that Moore has a (or close to) classic jumper.
I don't think that the principal element is exactly where the shot starts but that the shooter ultimately raises her arms over her head (from wherever the initiation point), leaps and in the most classic sense leans back as the ball is released.

I think the person credited for inventing and/or popularizing that shot was Paul Arizin of Philadelphia Warriors (1950-62).
Prior to that, the one and two-handed set shot was the preferred stroke, with the one-hander gaining ascendency (Bill Sharmaa's being the classic example of former and Bobby Wanzer, the latter).

I patterned my shot after Sharman, still take a hundred or so on a good day and even though he (and I) hopped a bit in the air during the release, this is not a true jump shot (which I added to my vocabulary but has sadly become extinct as have I).

For pure definitions, Saniya's shot as well as Tiff's seem more related to the set shot tradition rather than that of the jump shot.

Part of the problem is the negative connotation in the concept of the set shot being un-athletic or obsolete.

But of course, what I love about the woman's game (especially as Geno teaches it) is its resemblance to pro basketball of the 50's and 60's.
 
It's got to be extremely scary for opposing teams to hear Geno say our likely SG for next year reminds him of Sue Bird in regard to her ability to get the ball to the right place (which only she sees) at the right time in an inexplicable manner.

And, it's incredibly unlikely that Geno starts a freshman point guard. I believe it'd be unprecedented in non-injury scenarios.
Bria Hartley started as point guard I think! But I don't think we had other viable options that year. It was out of necessity. Or was she the 2 guard?
 
A late arrival to this discussion

We can all agree that Moore has a (or close to) classic jumper.
I don't think that the principal element is exactly where the shot starts but that the shooter ultimately raises her arms over her head (from wherever the initiation point), leaps and in the most classic sense leans back as the ball is released.

I think the person credited for inventing and/or popularizing that shot was Paul Arizin of Philadelphia Warriors (1950-62).
Prior to that, the one and two-handed set shot was the preferred stroke, with the one-hander gaining ascendency (Bill Sharmaa's being the classic example of former and Bobby Wanzer, the latter).

I patterned my shot after Sharman, still take a hundred or so on a good day and even though he (and I) hopped a bit in the air during the release, this is not a true jump shot (which I added to my vocabulary but has sadly become extinct as have I).

For pure definitions, Saniya's shot as well as Tiff's seem more related to the set shot tradition rather than that of the jump shot.

Part of the problem is the negative connotation in the concept of the set shot being un-athletic or obsolete.

But of course, what I love about the woman's game (especially as Geno teaches it) is its resemblance to pro basketball of the 50's and 60's.

History of The Jump Shot...courtesy of Google...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jump_shot_(basketball)
 
.-.
Yea, Ice is closer to correct on this one. Sorry DD. Just the way it is on this one. Chong's is not a classic jump shot. But then not a lot of girls shoot classic jumpshots, many just don't have the strength. Chong's isn't exactly a set shot either (circa 1950/60's). More of what I always called a "push shot" when I was coaching girls (daughter's team).

But then I wouldn't worry about it. If she can get it off and it goes in....good enough. It may change some as she gains strength throughout her college career. We'll have to see.
 
Bria Hartley started as point guard I think! But I don't think we had other viable options that year. It was out of necessity. Or was she the 2 guard?
She's always been pretty much a 2. Kinda of a combo, but I think more comfortable as a 2. Although in Geno's offense, it does not matter that much.

On the other hand Bird was a 2 coming out of HS, but switched over to become arguably the best 1 in the world. If you're good, you're good. And can do many things.
 
Hate to get into this so late, but you do not move your feet with a set shot, like most foul shots. If your feet leave the ground, it is a jump shot, classic or not, regardless of where the ball is started from. Let's close this thread! LOL!
 
Yea, Ice is closer to correct on this one. Sorry DD. Just the way it is on this one. Chong's is not a classic jump shot. But then not a lot of girls shoot classic jumpshots, many just don't have the strength. Chong's isn't exactly a set shot either (circa 1950/60's). More of what I always called a "push shot" when I was coaching girls (daughter's team).

But then I wouldn't worry about it. If she can get it off and it goes in....good enough. It may change some as she gains strength throughout her college career. We'll have to see.
I don't know how I am wrong.

All I said from the beginning is that Chong's shot is a jump shot. And that most women shoot it like that. Including Maggie Lucas.

I have also said that Chong does not shoot a classic jump shot, but she jumps when she shoots it, where or not she pushes it towards the basket or not.

That's it. It morphed into this crazy thread because Icebear said it wasn't a jump shot but a set shot. He changed it from that to a hybrid, whatever that is.

Are you saying you agree it's not a jump shot for Chong and Lucas?
 
Hate to get into this so late, but you do not move your feet with a set shot, like most foul shots. If your feet leave the ground, it is a jump shot, classic or not, regardless of where the ball is started from. Let's close this thread! LOL!

Don't agree
 
.-.
Ekmark's is a Jump Shot on at least the two I could see. I can't tell on the shot from behind her back. She had the ball up at her eyes and not down at the chin pushing it. She could move it higher and develop even better form.

Hybrid is the best name I can give to what Saniya does because jumping alone does not define a shot as a jump shot. Lay ups, hook shots, sky hooks all involve jumping but are not classic jump shots. Saniya and Maggies shot is properly called a "push shot" according to several sources I found. I didn't know it had a name. Stanford basketball player "Hank" Luisetti is credited with creating the one handed push shot including the small bunny hop in the 1930s. Luisetti twice led the nation in scoring and is in the Naismith Hall of Fame. Sometimes he shot a variation called the running one-handed push shot. Another player from that era with the one handed push shot was Jack Gray.

You did not respond to the video I posted for you of Maya teaching the proper shot. That segment is everything I have been trying to express. The cover photo captures the exact thing I have been describing.

Maggie Lucas does not shoot a jump shot either. Never has. Shoots the ball with a push from the chest and chin. She is deadly it simply isn't a classic Jump Shot, it is a push shot.

Further information from Wikipedia that encompasses the totality of this discussion.

Wikipedia,
"In basketball (and derivatives like netball), a jump shot or jumper is an attempt to score a basket by jumping, usually straight up, and in mid-jump, propelling the ball in an arc into the basket. It is accomplished by the player bringing his or her elbow up until it is aligned with the hoop, then sent towards the hoop in a high arc. It is considered the easiest shot to make from a distance. The purposes of the jump are to shoot from a higher position and therefore make it more difficult for the defender to block. It is also usually accomplished with one hand by the NBA players. It is the most effective in open play but can prove to be hard when there is a taller player in front of the shooter. There also exists another variant of a jump shot by shooting during the upwards movement of the jump to put more power behind the shot, this shot is usually done by woman or players lacking enough force to allow far distance shots. This shot has other advantages like a quicker release and therefore a faster execution time (comparable to the set-shot) and several disadvantages like a lower shooting height and less time for the shooter to aim in comparison to the mid-air jump shot."

Calling it a variant or a hybrid it is not the classic jump shot. That is all I have said from the beginning. Everything else has been attempting to clarify the language.

DD, you are the one worried about being right or wrong. That was never my interest in the subject matter.
 
Last edited:
So, wat do you call Chong's and Ekmark's long range shot? And 90% of womens long range shots?

Saniya's shot is based on the set shot of Bobby Wanzer (can't find film) he jumped a bit as he shot as did Sharman with one hand but the shot does not involve bring the ball up (if possible) over your head and using the upward momentum plus leg push to gain a huge height advantage a la Moore…which is my definition of a jump shot

Ekmark may be more of a hybrid haven't seen enough.
 
The difference is where the elbow is during the shot. The Maya video demonstrates this. Her elbow is even with the top of her shoulder (some players have the elbow even higher when shooting) That is the classic jumper. Saniya does jump on her shot but her elbow isn't shoulder height and is released in front of the body rather than overhead with the arm extended almost vertically. It depends (like almost everything else) on your definitions. I think the majority of women shoot the ball a lot closer to Saniya's form than Maya's
 
Are you saying you agree it's not a jump shot for Chong ?
Yes, I would not call that a "jump shot". Somewhere between a set shot and a jump shot. Like I said a push shot.

and Lucas?
I really can't comment on Lucas, haven't really seen her shoot. Don't really care to.
 
.-.
My apologies for keeping this thread alive but my opinion is that Maya, DT, and KML all shoot the jump shot like guys do. Many college women shoot it like Saniya and Tiff. They don't shoot it like guys do. As other have noted the only thing that counts is if it goes in. Sorry if I sound like a misogynist
 
My apologies for keeping this thread alive but my opinion is that Maya, DT, and KML all shoot the jump shot like guys do. Many college women shoot it like Saniya and Tiff. They don't shoot it like guys do. As other have noted the only thing that counts is if it goes in. Sorry if I sound like a misogynist
Don't you know? There is only one way to shoot a jump shot.

I know that because I have heard them say "nice push shot" during game broadcasts.
 
WTH

I could care less whether it's a jump or a push.

I only care if it goes in or not.

And whether or not we get the rebound if it doesn't !
 
From the ESPN play-by-play. Funny, they didn't call it a 3 point push shot.

12:484-5Saniya Chong made Three Point Jumper. Assisted by Bria Hartley.
12:39Chiney Ogwumike made Jumper.6-5
12:286-5Stefanie Dolson missed Three Point Jumper.
12:28Amber Orrange Defensive Rebound.6-5
12:256-5Foul on Saniya Chong.
12:06Mikaela Ruef missed Jumper.6-5
12:066-5Bria Hartley Defensive Rebound.
11:586-8
Saniya Chong made Three Point Jumper. Assisted by Bria Hartley.
 
My thought at the moment following Occam's Razor. A set shot is a SET shot and a jump shot is a JUMP shot.
 
From the ESPN play-by-play. Funny, they didn't call it a 3 point push shot.

12:484-5Saniya Chong made Three Point Jumper. Assisted by Bria Hartley.
12:39Chiney Ogwumike made Jumper.6-5
12:286-5Stefanie Dolson missed Three Point Jumper.
12:28Amber Orrange Defensive Rebound.6-5
12:256-5Foul on Saniya Chong.
12:06Mikaela Ruef missed Jumper.6-5
12:066-5Bria Hartley Defensive Rebound.
11:586-8
Saniya Chong made Three Point Jumper. Assisted by Bria Hartley.

Not sure that is who you want to cite as an authority. Why not look at how much there has been here for all of us to learn. A lot of good things to know that neither you nor I and I suspect many others knew. It is all good.
 
.-.
When the defense gets burned enough times because the defense moves out on Saniya and she blows by them for a layup or a dish off to Stef or Stewie, then they will have to give her space, which she will gladly use to shoot the three.
 
When the defense gets burned enough times because the defense moves out on Saniya and she blows by them for a layup or a dish off to Stef or Stewie, then they will have to give her space, which she will gladly use to shoot the three.

Well said. chrissaran.

As Geno once said, Saniya has the speed and ability to create her own shot whenever she wants…………wait till the UCONN fans see her step-back shot; or her tear drop floater, with either hand, as she drives to the hoop………..things of beauty!

We Boneyarders have some wonderful times ahead of us, as ALL our girls continue to get better and gain confidence under the wise tutelage of the UCONN coaching staff……………………….keeping my fingers crossed for quick recoveries for Kaleena and Morgan!
 
Well said. chrissaran.

As Geno once said, Saniya has the speed and ability to create her own shot whenever she wants…………wait till the UCONN fans see her step-back shot; or her tear drop floater, with either hand, as she drives to the hoop………..things of beauty!

We Boneyarders have some wonderful times ahead of us, as ALL our girls continue to get better and gain confidence under the wise tutelage of the UCONN coaching staff……………………….keeping my fingers crossed for quick recoveries for Kaleena and Morgan!
Lost in this stupid discussion on whether or not Chong shoots a jumper (she does), is the fact that she is an amazing player. In the short time I have seen her play in college she is making all the same moves I saw in her HS videos. Cross overs, ball fakes, finishing with her left or right, a deadly 3 point jumper, great court vision. She will be forced into more minutes and I think that is a good thing.
 
oh-lawd2-11.jpg
 
Lost in this stupid discussion on whether or not Chong shoots a jumper (she does), is the fact that she is an amazing player. In the short time I have seen her play in college she is making all the same moves I saw in her HS videos. Cross overs, ball fakes, finishing with her left or right, a deadly 3 point jumper, great court vision. She will be forced into more minutes and I think that is a good thing.

As Saniya gains more confidence, and the coaching staff grows more confident with her on the court, the UCONN faithful are in for a real treat! Amazing drives to the basket with either hand, accurate bullet passes from out of nowhere, nothing but net from the parking lot, and 110 % effort on both sides of the ball………… And when Saniya absorbs all the UCONN defensive schemes, her quick/speedy feet and hands will have more than their share of deflections and steals (and rebounds and blocks for a 5’8” guard).

Will Saniya ever have a bad game?? Sure she will. I’ve seen her fire up air balls, throw passes to nobody and off walls and charge into defenders……… but, as Geno says, she’s not afraid of anything………..and that’s how you learn…..by making mistakes…and that’s how you get better….by failing, and trying again.

I believe all the UCONN faithful will really enjoy watching Saniya grow as a player, and as a person, in her four years at UCONN.
 
So let me think about this a minute - MoJeff has a bad start and misses her 3s so she should lose her starting position to Saniya - but wait, MoJeff has better defense (missed by most in the shot-gate hysteria) so maybe she should not lose her start to Saniya. But the game was under so much better control whilst she was at the point according to some so maybe she should start over MoJeff. No wait, it was Bria who held everyone together so she should start for both herself and MoJeff...O, and Stef was missing her 3-point shot so maybe she should be replaced with KML - but wait, she is injured so forget that Stef stays...no wait, Stef didn't have the stats that Kiah had, plus she is ALWAYS in the upper post and NEVER down low so maybe Kiah should start for her. KML even though she is fabulous was not getting open so she should lose her starting position to Morgan Tuck who was hitting her three's today. Morgan plays post so she could also start for Stef who as we mentioned spends way too much time at the top of the key. Banks, poor thing is rusty so she is off to OZ to borrow the Tin Man's oil can. Stewey, forget that she was MOP of the final four, she shouldn't start at all because she is a shadow of her former self so maybe Stef should start for her since Kiah would be starting for Stef...but then when KML comes back from injury who should she replace in the starting line-up? well, she wasn't getting open so maybe she shouldn't start at all until she can figure out how to out-fox those darn double teams, same with Stewey. Bria, since she was the only one of the starters who performed to fan's expectations should actually be the coach and Geno should be benched because he obviously doesn't know what he is doing and should stay home watching the games whilst playing Candyland with his grandchildren and dining on osso buco, washing it down with a fine red table wine. But if Bria is coaching she obviously cannot play so now we are in real trouble.

See how crazy this gets?

Maybe some of the team managers could help out...
You were starting to lose me until my interest was peaked with the mention of osso buco...yum.
 
.-.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Forum statistics

Threads
168,492
Messages
4,578,257
Members
10,487
Latest member
husky62


Top Bottom