The article is a bit depressing and (in my humble opinion) a bit misinformed and some of the takes by the boneyard are out there.
I’ll begin with things that we (the school, the school’s leadership, coaches at different times (basically UConn, it’s employees, students and fans as a whole) did wrong from the announcement that RE was leaving:
- Hiring a has been who had most recently failed at his last collegiate head coaching position who was hired entirely for the wrong reasons (to provide job security to the then AD). O will add more to how this hurt us in terms of missed opportunities later.
- Replacing the has been (at a point where he drove the program downward to where our offensive line was a mess and we were losing to the type of program, FCS Towson in this case, that we would normally blow out prior to his hiring) with someone who somehow was undeniably worse, had lost touch with reality and refused assistance when it was offered.
- Replacing the head coach who was out of touch with reality with an attempted rerun of the coach who had built an actual program but unfortunately knew only one way (stripping it down to the bones and starting over) of building, something we did not have the time to afford. These shortcomings were exacerbated by the (second term) head coach not being able to conceptualize our leaving the AAC as anything other than abandoning football. Icing on the cake was the couple of years where the board willfully punished the athletic department out of anger towards the AD firing the basketball coach when he did.
Things that many of us need to realize; to be competitive at the level we want it to be in football, we need to actually build a program (think back to the mid 1990’s during the feud Calipari was running through the media with UConn/Jim Calhoun. Calhoun stated clearly that he was building a program, something that would be sustainable. It works the same way in all sports and even if someone can quickly build a competitive team, until the foundation is there as a program, having good teams will at best always be hit or miss.
To build a football program that will be what we want it to be we will need to reach the point where the entirety of the two deep is capable of stepping in and playing a full game as a starter. We need the third string to be capable of being a backup at every position and we need fourth string to be very early in their collegiate careers, capable of growing into players who belong on the two deep. We need a lot more players and more importantly, we need a lot more players with the potential to play at a P-whatever level if we want to perform at the level many of us claim they want us to perform at.
To get these players, it will take a lot more than merely NIL. If we’re looking at NIL to stock our roster, for example at an average of $200k per player, per year, it would take $17mm for the scholarship players. I really don’t believe this (an entire roster getting paid) is happening anywhere and in all candor, the schools that may be shelling out eight figures in NIL money are doing so for ten to twelve players. Maybe another dozen or so are getting a little something beyond that.
The first thing the football program needs to do is ease up on its fixation with in state players. Yes, it’s a feel good story when we land someone and he performs and yes, it’s better to not have an adversarial relationship with in state coaches, but the reality is, there is not enough talent generated in state, hell, in all of New England, to build a football program.
Our foundation needs to come from kids from the following states: New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Maryland, Virginia and Ohio. That five state region needs to fill half of our roster. Remove Ohio (and Virginia until a few years in) and that was where RE landed the bulk of the kids that he built the program the first time around with. Ten scholarship kids a year from those states should be the goal.
We need to view New York state and the entirety of New England as a recruiting region, attempt to land as many kids who belong at this level as possible but accept that some years there may be eight to ten that warrant scholarships while other years maybe three or four.
The Carolinas and Georgia (along with other SEC states outside of Florida & Texas) can be viewed as a region as can other B1G (Midwest) states, but combined, we most likely would be better served searching for diamonds in the rough in those areas.
Florida was a staple (Richardson recruited it well) at one time and we need to get there again. We also need to build a little on Texas (we have had some recent success) as those two states (to steal an old Sam Adams line) spill more HS football talent than we make.
When the Fiesta Bowl ended, we had a program (sadly, we haven’t been able to really say this for about a decade). One reality (at least in my opinion) was that RE’s lack of imagination had taken the program about as far as he could, and while the accomplishments warranted praise, believing we had reached the end goal (which some within the school, the athletic department and the state had claimed) was very small minded. I posted a thread on this board’s predecessor shortly before the Fiesta Bowl stating that we had reach base camp, that the mountain was ahead of us but we were in a position where we could climb that mountain. The biggest opportunity loss with the P hire was that a better hire could have taken us to another level and that wouldn’t have taken a lot. We were bringing back a defense that as it was could have competed with any in college football and, with some very minor fine tuning in scheme and approach, could have been much better. We were bringing back a lot of our offense and a creative mind who could also inspire recruits to want to play for him could have brought us to a serious level. What we’ve needed to do for about ten years now is start from square one.
I understand what Mora is saying about things being easier for recruiting if we were in a conference, I just don’t agree with him. Programs recruit to their identity and the conference a school is a member of is part of their identity (in some cases, it’s the bulk of their identity). Mora needs to sell an identity that doesn’t include conference membership (personally, I believe the superior level of opponent should work, but I’m not on the recruiting trail) and he’ll need a few years of recruiting classes under his belt to have the foundation needed to build a program. I get that at the moment all he can sell is faith and what has been visible isn’t something that will inspire a lot of faith. He needs to both believe it himself and project that belief to kids he’s trying to land.
Adding some complimentary pieces through the transfer portal and a stray high end NIL addition can make the team better, if the foundation is in place, but a team can’t be built this way. Too many players are involved (and they can’t be turned over constantly) and the bulk of them have to come from recruiting and have a few years in the system. As a basketball example, picture a team that historically is in the bottom third of a good conference. If through the transfer portal they end up with a nine man rotation (all good players) with three being on the team for a couple seasons while the other six are new, how well do you believe they’ll be able to play together? It will take them a while and it is possible that for an entire season they’ll never reach full cohesion and get knocked off by a lesser team. With a football team, something could look very similar if it is only 40% players new to the system. Having a solid, established team (say for example the 2010 UConn Huskies) and adding a couple stars at a couple key positions could well be enough to make the difference between a barely top 25 squad to a solid top five squad. Bringing in basically a new team would most often at best lead to results like what we’ve seen from Colorado, likely with less early season success and far less attention (as that is entirely due to the head coach).
As far as gaining membership in a conference we would want to join, there is one path. Beginning next season, the top ranked non-P(whatever) school gets a bid in the college football playoff. We need to build to the point where once the regular season ends, we’ll be ranked ahead of the best MWC, MAC, AAC, Sun Belt, whatever school (look where Coastal Carolina ended up a few years back). The minute we threaten to be able to walk away with a full (not split among conference members) share of CFP money, the big boys will take notice. Yes, it’s a tall order. Everything worth achieving is.