- Joined
- Aug 26, 2011
- Messages
- 13,895
- Reaction Score
- 35,822
I'm guessing this is reference to the Simon thread, but I'll give you one to mull over. I've been borrowing a ton of CDs from our library of stuff I find interesting for often strange reasons. One CD was a McCartney tribute. There were a ton of name artists who did very faithful renditions of McCartney songs (and surprisingly KISS was a highlight with Venus & Mars).
And then there was Dylan's version of "Things We Said Today". What made that song stand out was that to an average listener like myself, Dylan didn't seem to have a single F to give when recording that. He might as well have been gargling kerosene while spitting fire as he was "singing". And that's what makes it amazing.
Thanks for the YouTube link, which includes a basket full of polarized comments. Completely understandable.
The game I've played when seeing him live is, "How long will it be before I figure out what song this is?" The combination of crack musicianship, unfamiliar arrangements, atypical voicing, and irregularly comprehensible lyrics works for me. I have no need to convert anyone.