After March 29, the 1998-99 season moved to the top of the list, but those of us who had suffered through the previous decade can probably remember that the journey was actually not all that much fun all the time, due to expectations and pressure of trying to break through to the Final Four. We struggled with Marathon Oil in the exhibition game and we had 20-page threads trying to talk people off the ledge. Both St. John's games were high points, as was the Stanford game, but we also struggled with UMass, Pitt (the El-Amin scorers table game), lost at home to Miami, barely escaped Seton Hall in Big East quarters and we all wondered what was wrong with us. And to this day I will say that I've never HATED a sporting event more than I did the Gonzaga game. That thing was pure unadulterated hell. At least when George Mason happened, we already had two titles. Gonzaga would have been an overwhelmingly soul-crushing loss, and we were one more banked in Quentin Hall three from having it happen.
For season-long enjoyment, 1989-90 will always be tough to top. I enjoyed the 2001-02 season (the Caron Butler year), the 2008-09 season (despite the Final Four loss) and last year - since those were the years we re-emerged as a power and exceeded expectations. Last year had the slump late, but at least I felt comfortable about where the program was again.